refresh your memory to look at a picture that shows that very thing?â
âNo. Because I just looked at those pictures. They donât show that.â
The photo in Willâs hand was taken to the clerk and marked as an exhibit and handed to the officer on the stand.
âLook at the picture. Look very closely. Look through what is on the surface and look deep into the pictureâ¦deep into the photograph,â Will said.
âIâm sorry, but this is absurd, Your Honor,â the prosecutor blurted out. âThis is starting to sound like some kind of cheap parlor trickâmaybe defense counsel would like to hypnotize the officer into seeing something that isnât in that picture.â
But the judge was not looking at the lawyers, he was looking at the witness. And the officer had changed his expression as he was looking at the photo.
âDoes that photo portray something different than your recollection, officer?â the judge asked.
âNot exactly, butâ¦â the officer responded.
The prosecutor was on his feet again, but before he could say anything the judge reached over and grabbed the photograph from the witness and looked at it himself.
âThereâs nothing here, Mr. Chambers,â the judge said, âthat shows your client at all. All I see is a group of the other protestors sitting in front of the doors of the clinic.â
âYour Honor,â Will said, and now his voice was calm and deliberate, âlook at the glassâthe reflection in the plate-glass window of the clinicânot at the people sitting in the foreground of the photo, but into the glassâ¦â
The judge stared at the photo, and then silently passed it back to the witness. The officerâs shoulders slightly slumped. There was a little turning-up at one corner of his mouth, as if he were trying not to smile nervously.
âOfficer,â Will continued, âan overcast day that day?â
âYes.â
âA lot of reflection on the glassâalmost like a mirror?â
âYes, counselor, that would be one way to describe it.â
âAnd that reflection in the glass of the window showsâfaintly perhaps, but clearly enoughâit shows my client, red suspenders and all, standing off in the distance with his hands held over his head, and papers in them?â
âYes.â
âAnd there is someone else in the reflection of that glass, approaching him?â
âYes, counselor, there is.â
âWho is that?â
âThatâs me, I think, in that reflection, coming up behind himâ¦I guess to arrest him. While he was standing up.â
âAnd certainly not obstructing the doorway?â
âNo. To be honest, I guess not.â
The prosecutor wisely decided not to attempt the hopeless task of trying to rehabilitate his witness. He waived any redirect examination.
That is when Judge Ramington gave a short and dispassionate explanation for his decision to dismiss all of the criminal charges in the case of United States of America vs. William Tinney Heftland.
Will and Tiny walked out of the courtroom together. Tiny gave him a huge bear hug while Will fought back a little embarrassment in front of the court personnel walking by in the halls.
âOh, man, I owe you big-time,â Tiny said. âI donât just mean paying my bill. I will do that. But if there is some way I can repay you. Some favorâanything.â He was beaming.
âSure,â Will said. He was smiling too. Then Will hooked one of Tinyâs suspenders with his finger and pulled on it. âLucky suspenders.â
âYou got that right!â Tiny said and strode off with a big wave.
Will turned around to leave. He noticed the fragile-looking woman with the little babyâs feet pin, standing in the hallway, smiling at him and waving. He thought he heard her say something like âpraying for youâ again. Will gave her a half-wave