were still cold, feeling pensive and sad. Did anyone ever know what was happening with anyone else? Ever really know? She thought of how easily she had just disappeared from her own life for a few hours and of how easily she had simply returned, standing here now in sweatpants, reading the mail, nibbling one of her daughterâs cookies. How no one who knew her would ever guess, not just where she had been, but who . Someone else. She closed her eyes, pictured Noah lifting her in a bear hug, and felt an ache settle in her chest.
âMama, did you try the cookies me and Grandma made?â Erin leaned her elbows on the counter and propped her chin in her hands. No one had combed her hair today, and sheâd lost another tooth last week. She looked like a waif.
âYour cookies are absolutely great, honey-bunny.â She cupped Erinâs face in her hands, pushing her curly hair from her eyes. âAre you leaving some for Santa tonight?â
Erin nodded. âThatâs what Grandma asked me.â
âWhatâd Grandma ask?â Max slouched into a chair at the table.
Grace glanced at him. âYou look tired, honey. How was hockey today?â
â Bad . I really need new skates, mom.â The Bauer 400s in the back of her SUV.
âWell, did you ask Santa?
âMom.â
She grinned. âMax.â
From the next room came the shudder of the automatic garage opening. âDaddyâs home! Daddyâs home! Daddyâs home!â Jack shouted, hurrying for the door, yanking his mini suitcase on wheelsâhis oxygen canisterâbehind him.
âMama, why is your face so red?â Erin asked.
Grace lifted her palm to the side of her windburned face. âIs it?â
Â
âIf you could be any animal, what would you be?â Stephen read the question from the rectangle of colored paper Jack had pulled from the glass candy jar. The jar was filled with similar questions written on scraps of colored paper and folded into squares; If you could change the sky to any color besides blue, what color would you choose? If you could relive one day of your life, what day would that be?
âThis is so stupid,â Max said now around a bite of cheesesteak.
âAnytime you want to write your own questions,â Grace said.
â No, Mama,â Erin whined. âHeâll just write things about hockey.â
The question jar was a gift from one of Graceâs motherâs friends who was a creative writer. They took turns picking the questions each night.
Stephen grabbed a handful of potato chips. âWhat animal would you be, Erin?â
Erin cocked her head to the side, thinking. Grace caught Stephenâs eye and smiled. Heâd come home with Philly cheesesteaksâextra hot peppers for him, onions for Graceâtheir Christmas Eve tradition. And now a glass of Merlot, the snow fallingâ¦This is enough, she thought, guiltily thinking of Noah. This is more than enough.
âIâd be a polar bear,â Erin announced.
âYou mean a Teddy bear?â Max laughed.
âMama,â Erin whined. âWhy does he always make fun of my answers?â
âHeâs teasing,â Grace said. âTell us why you would be a bear.â She leaned forward and took another bite of cheesesteak. Sautéed onions dripped onto her plate.
ââCause I could play in the snow all day and not get cold.â She glared at Max, who rolled his eyes and muttered, âIâd be anything that lives alone.â
âLike a snake?â Erin said.
âNo, not like a snake,â Max mimicked.
Jack laughed. âMax is snake, Mama!â
Grace pointed at him. â You are a little instigator.â
âNo, you gator, Mama.â
Erin giggled. âNot alli gator, silly.â
âIâd be a bird,â Grace said. A brown pelican. At this time of the season! Noah had once traced his finger over her sternum and told her,