ever happened with you and Mom before?â Eleanor asks, but she knows it hasnât. She knows this is the day I have moved from special little Silly who needs protecting and turned into just another one of the girls.
Itâs weird, how something can feel good and bad at the same time.
âWhatâd you do to upset her?â Marla says.
âI hate this house,â I say, which doesnât answer any of them, exactly, but also answers all of them, I think.
Five
T he curtains are drawn and the room is dark, except for a crack of light peeking through the bottom of Eleanorâs closet. Astrid and Eleanor picked out heavy navy curtains when they decorated their new room, and they almost never leave them open, so itâs night in here even when itâs daytime everywhere else. Astrid says she works better with just a few night-lights on, and Eleanor is almost never inside anyway. So the way the closet light breaks through the darkness right now is unmistakable. A cut in the night.
I know instantly thatâs where their secrets are kept.
I guess closets are where we all keep our secrets. Dadkeeps the books that are too adult for us to read in his closet. Astrid and Eleanor have always kept pictures of boys they like in their closets. In my closet in our old house I had a story I wrote about me being LilyLeeâs sister and living with LilyLeeâs family. Of course now thereâs only other peopleâs discards in my closet, which is yet another reason to hate the New Hampshire house. I donât even get a place to store my secrets.
Momâs secrets must be in closets too. Maybe she keeps extra bottles in there or something.
âI want to go in,â I say, pointing to the line of light below their closet door.
âNo!â Marla says, her voice cracking and desperate. A whole complicated series of looks are exchanged between the twins, and I understand that even if Marla was invited in before me, weâll always be the younger ones and theyâll always have each other.
âShe needs it too,â Astrid says to Eleanor. âDonât you think?â
âIâm more than a whole year older,â Marla says. Itâs not the first time sheâs used that as an argument for something. Sheâs a stickler for a certain kind of fairness: if she wasnât allowed to swim to the deeper part of the lake until she turned eight, I shouldnât be allowed to do it until I turn eight a whole year later. Since she got a new bike when sheturned ten, I shouldnât have one when Iâm only nine. She wants her extra year on me to matter in some measurable way, whereas Iâd rather pretend she and I are twins too, able to do everything together like Eleanor and Astrid.
âYou canât leave me out there with Mom when youâre all in here,â I say, not realizing how true that is until Iâve said it. If thereâs a tornado, you all hold hands and anchor one another so that no one gets swept up alone. We are in the middle of a tornado, and itâs not okay for them to hold on to one another and sacrifice me to the spinning, violent force. âItâs not about how old I am. I canât do it all by myself. Didnât you hear how she talked to me? I canât be included in that but not included in this.â I get a pang of fear that they wonât listen. That Iâll have Mom calling me a disappointment on the other side of their bedroom door while they all escape into secrets without me.
âI shouldnât be lonely when I have three sisters,â I say, like feelings and families are simple scientific facts. Cause and effect.
Thereâs a certain kind of shock on Eleanorâs face, and I think sheâs never heard me say so many words at once, and so clearly.
âWeâre in charge, okay?â she says.
I nod. Itâs not anything new. Theyâre always in charge.
Marla makes a series of noises that must