the killer knew this area like he knew his own skin.
Gradyâs frown deepened. âLook, Harris, I hired you because youâve got the best homicide training from one of the biggest cities in the world. So Iâm glad I have you available for something like this. But youâre not from around here, so you donât know the Amish.â
I huffed. âI was born and raised in Quarryville. You know that.â
âYeah, but you probably had about as much dealings withthem in high school as I did, which is to say the occasional ogle at a horse and buggy. Iâve been an officer of the law in Lancaster County for fifteen years and I know their culture. Thereâs never been a murder among the Amishâever. And I especially canât imagine one involving a beautiful young English girl in the middle of the night. Why would she even be out there with them? These people donât associate with girls like her. Somebody she knew killed her and dumped her out there, someone with a car. We need to find that person.â
I bristled instinctively. Jane Doe was young and perhaps a little too made-up, but that didnât make her a âlike herâ in my mind. I was defensive of my vic, which was foolish and sentimental, but it was a sentimentality Iâd been prone to ever since I became a cop. It helped me stay motivated when things got tough, so I didnât fight it. But I didnât have to voice it and make myself look like a sap either.
âI donât disagree. Itâs probably an ex-boyfriend or a stepdad, someone she knew well. Iâm just saying we need to look at all possibilities with a clear eye, not go into it with a list of wonâts and couldnât-bes, because thatâs the surest way to screw yourself over.â I folded my arms over my chest, prepared to be stubborn. Theyâd brought me in to do a job, and I was going to do it.
Grady visibly relaxed. âIâm not asking you to ignore them. Justâwe have to be circumspect. Know what that word means, Harris?â
Now he was just yanking my chain. I laughed. âCircumspect? Kind of a personal question, isnât it? Are you asking me if Iâm Jewish? I donât even have the equipment for that, in case you hadnât noticed.â
Grady rolled his eyes. âThatâs just gross. Iâll take that for a no. Which is why you and me are partners on this case.â
âWhat?â
I thought for a moment that Grady was still pulling my leg. There were a whopping eight investigators in the Violent Crimes Unit, including Grady himself. I wasnât surprised to be partnered up for a case this serious, but I had no idea Grady still took cases himself in addition to overseeing the lot of us.
âThis could get ugly,â Grady said quietly. âI need your expertise, Harris, because it has to be solved fast. But I need to be in it myself. I know the area. I know the people and the . . . delicacies, for lack of a better word. I already discussed it with the chief. He thinks itâs a good idea.â
I couldnât help thinking they wanted a man involved, maybe because the Amish would take a man more seriously. But the goal was to solve the case. I wasnât going to argue with what would work.
âAre you going to want to lead the interviews?â I asked in a neutral voice.
âNah. Like I said, youâve got a lot more recent homicide experience than me. Besides, I want to see you in action.â He smirked.
âOkay,â I said slowly. âIf you watch me very, very carefully, you might learn something.â
Grady snorted. âLike how to wipe my ass and text at the same time the way you New Yorkers do? Lookinâ forward to it. Hell, letâs go get started on those interviews. The Amish are early risers.â
â
It was mid-afternoon when Grady pulled into Ezra Beilerâs farm. On my iPad were interviews with every member over the