father killed a man.â
âAnd you didnât know about this?â
She shook her head. âIf he did, he got away with it, David.â
I let out a breath, too loudly. âHe confesses this in the letter?â
âThatâs all the letter is about,â she said. âItâs very matter of fact. I would rather have learned that he had a mistress or that I had been adoptedâ¦â
âWhy would he write it down?â
Her hair had come loose again. She swept it back and said, âI think he finally wanted me to know. After heâd been diagnosed, and knew he didnât have long. He knew Iâd take charge, and Iâd find it. But the crimeâif it happenedâwas in 1966.â
âWas your father the kind of man who would kill somebody?â
âI thought he was when he found my boyfriend in bed with me when I was seventeen,â she said. âAnd I mean that. He had a bad temper. And heâd had to have been tough to make it in Cleveland. But, no, nothing like that.â
âWho was this man he killed?â
âIt doesnât say. Now, donât dismiss me. I know what youâre thinking. He only refers to him as âZ.â He writes that he felt he had no choice, but nobody would have believed him. But thereâs so little to itâjust a few sentences. No sense of really why this happened, what drove him to do it. There are so many questions.â
âDana,â I said, âIâm sorry to hear this. I know itâs got to be a shock, coming on top of losing your father. And Iâm honored youâd look me up. But I donât really see how I can be any help.â
âThis is what you do, David,â she said, her eyes bright. âCrime and history. I remember you said that every historianâs dream is to discover a letter in an attic.â
âI think I probably said something like a letter from Abe Lincoln or George Washingtonâ¦â
âWell, itâs not that,â she said primly. âBut I need to know if my father really did kill a man.â
I tried to watch her closely, but instead I felt the largeness of the room around us. My eyes drifted to the Republic on my desk, with headlines about continuing drought, a twenty-car pileup on Interstate 10 and a six-year-old boy found chained by his parents in a box. So much trouble in my city. I said, âDo you really want to know? Sometimes itâs better not to know everything.â
âYes,â she said quietly. âI have to know. Wouldnât you want to know if your father was a murderer?â She pushed the envelope at me. I didnât touch it. She said, âAnyway, thatâs not all. The other thing he writes is where we can find the body.â
I felt relief. âThen itâs clear. If you really fear that this is possible, youâve got to go to the police back in Ohio.â
She shook her head violently, unleashing a small cascade of hair. âNo, David. I came to the right police. The man is buried right here in Arizona.â
5
A few days later, I checked out a Ford Crown Vic from the sheriffâs motor pool. Lately Iâd been riding the bus in anticipation of Phoenix finally finishing the light-rail line on Central; when that happened, I could take the train the mile-and-a-half between the house and my office in the old courthouse. With this well-used piece of county property, I drove west and left the city. I tried to leave the city, but it kept spreading out. The cotton and alfalfa fields that stood when I was a kid had long since been covered with subdivisions. Now many of them, once new safe suburbia, had become slums. The little farm towns had turned into cities, densely packed red tile rooftops stretching to the horizon. Farther out, the remnants of farms sat like an unwanted tenant as the shopping strips, car dealerships and houses encroached. Signs hawked new developments from a dozen builders.