she shouldnât be. Thatâs why you sent me away, because I . . .â My voice fades. Itâs still so hard to say, even though Iâve had five days to wrap my head around the truth. I try again, forcing the words from my mouthbefore they can shoot back down my throat. âBecause I supposedly killed her.â
Mom crosses the room and sits in the armchair by the fireplace. âPrincipal Gubbins called the night of the cafeteria incident to tell us that Miss Parsippany was still unconscious. Chances of her waking up were slim. Annika was making a special, rare exception in accepting a student after the semester had already started, and she needed a decision right away. I didnât want you to miss the chance to attend the best reform school in the country, so I enrolled you without waiting to hear that your substitute teacher had officially passed.â
If Kilterâs a reform school, Iâm Frosty the Snowman. But unlike this one, that conversation can wait.
âBut once you knew she was okay,â I say, âwhy didnât you come get me?â
Mom shrugs. âBecause you threw the apple.â
âBecause I saw Miss Parsippany heading for the fight. She was small. The kids were big. I wanted to break it up before anyone got hurt.â
âYou couldâve run for other teachers.â
âThere was no time.â
âYou couldâve yelled across the cafeteria.â
âIt was too noisy.â
Sinatra starts hiccupping again. As Dad jumps up and hurries to the record player, I consider what Momâs implying. She knows I didnât kill anyone, but she doesnât know everything I did at Kilterâintentionally or otherwise. Which means . . .
âYou think Iâm a bad kid. Still.â
Her head tilts to one side. The corners of her eyes soften. âI think no oneâs perfect. And a little self-improvement, whatever its motivation, is never a bad thing.â
âWhat about Parentsâ Day?â
âWhat about it?â
I take a deep breath. Here it comes: the question Iâve been struggling to guess the answer to for weeks. Itâs a million times more perplexing now.
âWhy did you tell everyone I was a murderer?â
She sips her coffee. Rolls it around her mouth. Swallows. âI didnât know you hadnât told your classmates.â
âStill. Parentsâ Day was in November. You knew then that it wasnât true, and you said it anyway.â
âI was nervous. Excited. It just came out.â
She says this lightly, easily, like it was a silly joke people laughed at, then forgot. But they didnât forget. Lemon, Abe, Gabby, Elinor . . . They didnât talk to me after that. They barely looked at me.
Mom stands up. She comes over to me, puts her arms around my shoulders, and kisses the top of my head. âIâm sorry. It was an accident.â
An accident. I can relate, canât I?
Iâm still trying to decide, when the doorbell rings. Down the hall, the front door opens and closes. Heavy footsteps thump toward us. A low voice calls out, âHo, ho, ho!â
And my worst nightmare comes to life. Again.
âBartholomew John?â
He freezes just outside the living room, his face hidden behind the bright red petals of the poinsettia plant heâs holding.
âWhat are you doing here?â I look up at Mom. âWhat is he doing here?â
Her face is white. Still around my shoulders, her arm is tense.
âBJ works part-time at Cloudview Cards and Carnations.â Dad hurries past us. âHe meets all our houseplant needsâat half price.â
Itâs a good thing Mom has me in a vise grip, because I canâtfeel my legs. My head swirls with images. I barely make out soggy fish sticks. A mouthful of braces behind a lopsided sneer. Fists flailing and apples flying.
âBut itâs Christmas,â I say, fighting to keep my