He made everyoneâs life wretched. I daresay most people were relieved rather than shaken by his demise.â
Changing the subject as they reached the top of the stairs, Cummins said, âI saw the notice of your engagement in the Times . I wish you both every happiness.â
âThank you, sir. I hope youâll have an opportunity to meet Jean sooner rather than later.â
âSet a date, have you?â
âChristmas, I think.â
Cummins nodded. They had reached his door. âBy the bye. A warning. The Chief Superintendent is in a foul mood. That case in Northumberland blew up in Penvellynâs face. Three witnesses, and theyâve recanted, to a man.â
Both Rutledge and Cummins had been aware from the start that Inspector Penvellyn had not been the best choice to take on Northumberland. A Cornishman, heâd never been north of Birmingham. He knew very little about the border counties. And that business in Alnwick had needed delicate handling.
âBowles isnât thinking of sending me there in his place?â Rutledge asked, realizing that the word warning might mean just that. Heâd been given leave on Friday for the Gordonsâ party, but Bowles could rescind that as quickly as heâd granted it.
âNo, I think Martin is going to be the unlucky man. But on a lighter note,â Cummins continued, âDavies has run into an odd case. In Somerset actually, a village outside Bristol. In the night someone crept into a churchyard and blackened several graves. Sludge more than paint, according to his report, and the very devil to clean. I doubt theyâll have it removed in six monthsâ time. Nothing else touched. And the graves werenât even in the same part of the churchyard. Random vandalism, apparently.â
âWhose graves were they? Men, women, children?â Rutledge was intrigued.
âMen, every one of them. The vicar couldnât think of any connection among them. Which is not to say there isnât one. Various occupations, various ages. Farmers, shopkeepers, a doctor. Davies combed through their lives and came up with nothing of note.â
âHow long has the vicar been in that parish?â
âA good point. Ten years. But Davies asked living relatives, and they couldnât provide an answer either.â
âDid he find the culprit?â
âDavies did his best, but no, he came up empty-handed. The vicar is quite upset. He seemed to think the villainâs next target might be the church itself. Itâs old, there could be serious damage done there.â
âDid the victims die at the same time? A calamity of some sort?â
âDavies and the vicar looked for a pattern, but there was none. Had they died in the same monthâodd yearsâconsecutive yearsâmurdered? Any variation he could think of failed to hold up. And there were no witnesses, if you donât count the churchyard owl. A constable made his rounds at ten, then again at midnight, and went away home.â He shrugged. âWhoever it was had a clear field for some hours. Well, needless to say, Davies isnât in the best of moods either.â Cummins tossed his hat to the top of a file cabinet and said, âI thought youâd be interested. So was I. If you think of anything Davies hasnât tried, tell me.â
Rutledge stood in the doorway. âWhy was the Yard involved in the first place? It appears from what youâve said to have been a petty crime.â
Cummins nodded. âApparently the vicar has a few connections of his own. He complained to his bishop, and someone at the Home Office listened. It was a shocking scene, of course, and it unsettled the entire village.â
Rutledge smiled. âToo bad Davies failed to uphold the honor of the Yard.â
âIâll wager it was nothing more than a prank or a dare by localyouths. They may still come forward, if their consciences are guilty enough.