violent-tempered unstable woman, after exasperating her husband, fell off the top of a tall ladder. To want a person dead isnât murder.â
Dr. Wendover shifted around. âIt is, morally.â
âWeâre not Morality, weâre Law.â
âUm; itâs a natural law that where thereâs a will thereâs a way.â
âWell, the way was the ladder. How did he will her to fall off, and neatly, plumb on her head! He couldnât have pulled her off. Six people were on the line in between.â
Dr. Wendover did not answer but turned back to looking at the ladder itself. Sergeant Skillin tried to rouse him:
âWhy did you pull it down?â
âWhy, itâs our last witness.â
âItâll tell us nothing we donât know. We know everyone who handled it. Doubt if youâd even find the poor womanâs fingerprints on it.â
Evidently no longer listening, the Doctor had strolled up to the ladderâs head, where the hinged back-supports joined onto the top of the flight of steps. Sergeant Skillin was reaching the end of his tether.
âHere,â he called out, excusing himself for his tone of voiceâbecause old Wendover was really daydreamingââif you want to interrogate that dumb scantling, you wonât get anything from its head, from that old clotheshorseâs mouth,â he chuckled, his natural good temper restored by his own small joke. âIts feet, at my end, are the only thing that might help us. But, of course, Iâve questioned them.â
He bent down and looked at the undersurfaces of the ladderâs ends, now visible. âYâsee, as true and firm as you could wish or, rather, as we could not wish.â He shook the ladderâs struts and tried the steps. âNo play there. These ladders are new and of good workmanship.â
Dr. Wendover turned. âThen they were purchased lately.â
âYes, Dr. Smirke had bought them a couple of months ago. He told the man who provided them, and whom heâd dealt with for some years, that he was tired of those dangerous lean-to ladders and had nearly had an accident or two by their slipping on this smooth floor. This year, he said, heâd have safe ladders before he started decorations for the Christmas party. And they are safe.â
The Doctor assented, âHe was certainly a careful man.â That did not, however, take his attention from the ladder head at his feet. Finally, as Sergeant Skillin was strolling to the door, he roused himself to call him back. âYou said we shouldnât get anything from this old clotheshorseâs mouth. I like your simile, but I venture to differ from you in your dismissal of this witness.â
âWell, youâll have to do the translating and, remember, not to me, your indulgent friend, but to a court and an expensive defending lawyer.â
âYouâll at least let me rehearse the part in front of you.â
âOh, go ahead.â
âFirst, be so kind as to bend yours a little, so that you may see the witnessâs mouth.â
Sergeant Skillin did consent to bend his head sideways. âWhy, thatâs only a handhold.â Sure enough, just under the broad platform top-step, in the side piece of wood which supported it, a space was cut, big enough to put a hand through.
âAnd, look, thereâs the companion one on the other side.â The Sergeant drew himself up, glad to counterquiz the Doctor. âThey must be handholds for carrying the ladder.â
âNo; if the ladder was a four-foot one, instead of four times that height, you might carry it so. But, see, this big thing, if it is carried, must be carried longways; its weight would require two hands, and, then, if this is a handhold, it should be at right angles to the way it is actually cut. Besides, these cuts werenât made by the maker. That sawing isnât professional carpentry. That he troubled to