Dundas about the activities of radical dissidents. The only thing Fintry is to be thanked for was that he inspired two major English language poems, To Robt. Graham of Fintry, Esq., with a request for an Excise Division and To Robert Graham of Fintry, Esq . which are masterful, creative reworking of themes initially found in Swiftâs perhaps greatest poem, On Poetry: A Rhapsody . The latter Burns poem was of such quality, in fact, that only now has it become known that for years, a fragment of it, slightly bowdlerised, has been attributed to Coleridge. As well as learning from Swift, Burnsâs thinking on poetry and patronage was influenced by Dr Johnson. As he wrote:
It is often a reverie of mine, when I am disposed to be melancholy, the characters & fates of the Rhyming tribe â there is not among all the Martyrologies that ever were penned, so rueful a narrative as Johnsonâs Lives of the Poets .â In the comparative view of the Wretches, the criterion is not what they are doomed to suffer, but how they are formed to bear.
Nor does Burnsâs analysis of the desperate life of the late-eighteenth century poet, an age replete in prematurely terminated and self-destructive careers, yield, especially in the two Fintry poems, to the quality of Johnsonâs psychological and sociological grasp of what was taking place. His rhetorical style may not be ours but there is actually little self-indulgence in what he sees as his own fate and that of his immediate predecessors. This is particularly so with regard to his beloved Edinburgh predecessor, Robert Fergusson, as mentioned in To William Simson :
(O Fergusson ! thy glorious parts
Ill suited lawâs dry, musty arts!
My curse upon your whunstane hearts,
   Ye Enbrugh Gentry!
The tythe oâ what ye waste at cartes
   Wad stowâd his pantry!)
He was not to know that not only was he to share Fergussonâs pains in his life but, like Fergusson he was also to be pursued beyond the grave by the vilification of genteel Edinburgh and by its master spirit, Henry Mackenzie, who never forgave Fergussonâs fine parody of The Man of Feeling in his poem, The Sow of Feeling . Underneath Mackenzieâs simpering mask was a malice easily provoked by slights to his vanity or, in Burnsâs case, if he felt the reactionary power base, which propped up his doubtful talent and his monstrous ego, endangered.
THE RADICAL BURNS
It is not inevitable that out of a background of constantly threatening poverty, a profound sense of communal economic and political dissolution, bloody international warfare on land and sea, failure to make a living after being, initially, declared a poetic genius, a revolutionary spirit will emerge. Oliver Goldsmith, a poet Burns loved, came to the political conclusion that what the age needed to restrain the greedy, fractious aristocracy was an increase in the authority of the King. Burns, however, manifestly belongs to the temporarily dominant radical British literary culture which emerged with the loss of America. Hence all his actual and epistolary connections with the English radicals: Mary Wollstonecraft, Helen Maria Williams, William Roscoe, Dr Wolcot (pen name, Peter Pindar). Hence his persistent seeking to publish in not only Edinburgh and Glasgow radical newspapers but, from the very beginning of his career, in London ones. Hence the resemblance in hispoetryâs theme in image, if rarely in quality, to the outpouring of Scottish and English radical protest poetry accompanied by his signal influence on the dissenting Ulster radical poets. Hence the manifest parallels, albeit they were quite unaware of each other, with William Blake. De Quinceyâs definition of Burns as a Jacobin was anything but singular among the English radicals. John Thelwall, Wordsworth and Coleridgeâs political mentor, greatly admired Burns. James Perry, editor of the anti-government Morning Chroni cle not only