club. Itâs a false syllogism to suggest that indicates Iâm inââ
âDid you just say âsyllogismâ?ââ
âWhat? No. Maybe.â
âThis is exactly my point. Youâre in the chess clubââ
âIâm
not
in the chess club.â
ââand you use words like âsyllogism.ââ
âWhat, Iâm not manly if I use big words?â
âYou still play D&D.â
I donât have an answer for that. He sits back and crosses his arms, triumphant: check and mate.
Itâs true. Danny, Steve, Paul, and I have been playing faithfully for four years, introduced to it by the assistant librarian. The librarian vanished after a few months, at which point our parents sat us down individually for awkward conversations about whether or not heâd ever done anything that made us feel
uncomfortable.
Thatâs when Josh taught me the term
pedophile,
which he described in traumatic detail. But the four of us keep playing secretly. When we talk about it at schoolâif everâwe use code. We all instinctively understand where D&D players are ranked in the junior high school social hierarchy and that itâs probably time to hang up our dice. Still, you donât just walk away from an honestly earned level-nineteen half-elf cleric.
âIsaac,â says Josh, âyou canât keep being a nervous little kid who runs to Mom for everything.â
âI donât run to Mom for everything. Sometimes I run to Dad.â
âYou know why youâre such a smartass? Because youâre weak, and scared of everything. You want to keep being a scared smartass?â he says. âHuh?â he adds when I donât respond.
âHold on, Iâm trying to think up a smartass answer.â
He snorts and sits back in his chair. âYouâre smarter than me, Isaac. Youâre certainly smarter than I was at your age. And you know what youâre like? All those supersmart, weakass Jews who got slaughtered by the Nazis.â
There it is, finally. Iâm surprised it took him so long to get to it. Josh, who my dad says always wants to refight the Second World War. Josh, who transformed himself into SuperJewâthe single most effective thing he ever did to annoy my parentsâand who used to go around Edina wearing a yarmulke. A black one with skulls and crossbones on it.
âThe world doesnât need any more weak Jews.â
Iâm not sure what an appropriate response is to that, so I say nothing. I sip at my lemonade, avoiding his gaze, watching a squirrel skitter nervously along the branches of the tree that rises above the deck, the leaves making shooshing and rustling noises as he agitates his way along. I can feel Josh watching me.
âHowâs your lemonade?â he asks.
âFine, I guess.â
âGood.â
He takes another drink of his lemonade, observing me, thinking. Heâs silent long enough that I finally look over at him. His expression makes me even more nervous.
He finishes his drink and puts his glass down, then turns in his chair so that heâs square to me. âIsaac,â he says, âweâve got a very short time until your bar mitzvah.â
âI
know.
â
âAnd you know what weâre going to do?â
Oh no.
âJosh, all I need to do is memorize my haphtarah.â
âWeâre going to make you into a man.â
âJosh, no. Please. I just want to go and watch my haphtarah DVDââ
âYou know, in primitive cultures, the boys would have to go on a quest or pass some sort of painful challenge before they could be declared a true man.â
âThatâs fantastic, Josh.â
âTheyâd put them out in the wilderness to fend for themselves, to fight other villagersââ
âWe live in the suburbs.â
âThereâs ritual tattooing . . .â
âGreat.â
â . . .