again, âWhy would they pretend the diamond was stolen?â
Mrs. Roth sighed. âThey were very good friends of mine,â she said finally.
Hero glanced at her. She fiddled with her shoelaces, waiting for a response. Why wasnât she answering? And then she thought she understood.
âYou can tell me,â Hero said slowly. âI wonât tell anyone. Thereâs nobody I could tell anyway.â
âNo?â Mrs. Roth turned to her, and her gaze was steady. âYouâre like me, then. Thereâs nobody I can tell either. Eleanor was my closest friend. Isnât it strange? Sheâs the one Iâd most like to talk to about it, and sheâs gone.â Her lips twitched. âThereâs a wonderful Emily Dickinson poem:
âIâm Nobody! Who are you?
Are you â Nobody â too?
Then thereâs a pair of us?
Donât tell! theyâd advertise â you know!
How dreary â to be â Somebody!
How public â like a Frog â
To tell oneâs nameâthe livelong Juneâ
To an admiring Bog!
âDo you know that one?â
Hero shook her head, smiling. âIf anything gets quoted at our house, itâs usually Shakespeare. But I like that.â
âI do, too,â Mrs. Roth said. She rested her head against the post again and looked out into the garden. âAll right, then. Why would Arthur and Eleanor Murphy hide a diamond?â
Hero waited in the warm silence, eager for her to continue.
Finally she spoke again. âTwo years ago, Eleanor became ill. It was cancer, very advanced; no one had any hope. But there was a treatment in Mexico, something experimental and very expensive. It wasnât covered by their health insurance. Arthur was certain it was the only thing that would save her.â
Mrs. Roth seemed to be talking to herself now. âThey couldnât afford it. Arthur wanted her to sell the necklace. Eleanor refused. She thought the necklace might have some sort of historical importance. The Vere family was descended from British nobility apparently.â
âBut if it was the only way to pay for the treatment she needed,â Hero protested, âwouldnât she do it to save her own life?â
âI donât think she had any confidence she could be saved,â Mrs. Roth said. âShe wasnât a young woman. She seemed to accept it, that she was going to die.â
âReally?â Hero couldnât imagine that. âShe just gave up?â
âI donât think it was giving up. Her health declined noticeably about a year ago. It was a terrible thing to watch. Sheâd always been such a vibrant person, full of interests and curiosities. She became very weak. She couldnât read. We couldnât do the crosswords anymore. Arthur was just desperate. Iâd never seen him like that.â Mrs. Roth hesitated.
Hero sunk her chin into the hollow between her kneecaps, breathing the salty, grassy smell of her own skin. âSo you think he did it? You think Mr. Murphy took the diamond himself?â
Mrs. Roth nodded. âI do, yes. I think the police were right. I think Arthur reported the diamond stolen for the insurance money. He thought it was the only way to save his wife.â
âDid he get the money? Did he take her to Mexico?â
Mrs. Roth straightened, seeming to come out of herreverie. âNo, not in time. Because of the investigation, the insurance people delayed payment for months and months. Eleanor died last fall. So it was all for nothing. And Arthur couldnât bear to live here without her.â
Hero stared at the ordinary shingled profile of her familyâs house. It looked so much like the other houses on the street, with its peaks and dormers, its aging shutters and bay windows. Who would have thought it had such a history?
âBut why does anyone think he hid the diamond in the house?â she asked. âIt would make more