âDelighted to make your acquaintance. Although I fancy youâd be more delighted to make the acquaintance of a peach pie and a cup of tea.â
Billy searched the peddlerâs face for a cue. Jonathan nodded. âSheâs only asking us to tea, son, not the governorâs ball.â
âIâuh, yes, please, thank you, maâam,â Billy blurted.
Sophie tucked one hand under Billyâs arm and the other under Jonathanâs, but Billy pulled away, face stricken with a spasm of guilt. âPhizzy!â Billy said, glancing at the floppy-eared gray gelding who nodded sleepily at the gate. âI got to see to Phizzy first. Itâs me job.â Billyâs cheeks flushed with shame.
âIâm sure Phizzy will excuse you for a bit,â Sophie said.
âIâm sorry, maâam, but you see Phizzy
needs
me.â Billy broke away to rush back to the horse. Jonathan caught bits of murmured Irish apologies as Billy caressed Phizzyâs nose.
Jonathan started to apologize for Billyâs breach of manners, but Sophie cut him off with a laugh. âLet the boy be. It looks like he loves that old horse as much as you do.â
âWhereâs Eldad?â Jonathan asked.
âThere was some hubbub down to Chester Ainesworthâs. He went to see what the to-do was all about. He should be back soon.â Sophie nudged her cousinâs elbow. âGo show your boy where to put Phizzy. Iâll have tea ready when you come in.â
Jonathan and Billy led Phizzy to the wagon shed and backed the wagon in. Theyâd just finished unhitching the gelding whena long shadow loomed in the doorway and a gruff voice boomed, âThereâd better not be any tin left in that thing.â
Jonathan spun around to greet the tall, gray-haired man. âEldad! Ainât you a sight!â He gave his cousinâs husband a strong handshake and a hearty thump on the back. âSo whatâs this Sophie said about you chasing down some hullabaloo in town?â
âChasing down a lot of gossip, is more like it.â Eldadâs hooked nose wrinkled with his scowl. âSeems Jacob Fairley caught himself a thief and a murderer.â
âA murderer in Chauncey? Now that does beat all.â Jonathan returned to Phizzy, looping the geldingâs reins through an iron ring while Billy fetched his halter.
Eldad leaned his long frame against the doorjamb and watched the two work. âThe story is he came out bold as brass, looking to get his horse shod. But Jake said he could tell it was stolen, just from the looks of this fella. Foreign, I guess, and shifty-eyed.â
Jonathan paused in the middle of trading bridle for halter. âThe fella or the horse?â
âThe fella.â
âOh. You seen him yourself?â
âI couldnât get in. The whole town must have been crammed into Chesterâs parlor and yard. By the time I got there, a snake couldnât have slipped in the door.â
âSo whereâs this foreign murderer from?â Jonathan gathered up bridle and harness, then gave them to Billy to store in the back of the wagon.
âSeems he worked for some fella up in Massachusetts. Killed the whole familyâslit their throats while they were in their beds, stole their goods and took off. Some say heââ Eldad cast a glance toward Billy and lowered his voice. âSome say he assaulted the mother and daughters before heââ Eldad ran his thumb across his throat.
âFunny I ainât heard nothing about it. You know how folks love talking murder with a peddler.â Jonathan gestured for Billy to take Phizzy out to a little pen next to the barn. The men leanedon the fence and watched the gelding shake himself all over, then crumple into the grass with a contented sigh. In a moment, all four enormous hooves were waving in the air as the horse erased the harness marks and sweat stains in the grass.
Eldad