that you didnât know what he looked like, and by mistake you shot Mr. Michael Milano?â
âSomebody else said that was him.â
âAnd you took that personâs word?â Casabielle said.
âYes.â
âThat was enough for you to kill somebody?â
âAt the time, yeah.â
*Â Â Â *Â Â Â *
A COUPLE of murders later, Casabielle brought up a guy named William OâBrien. The Hill had been looking for a tough ex-con named Ralph DeMasi, and OâBrien was driving him on Morrissey Boulevard in Dorchester. They had just left a meeting at which theyâd been trying to buy guns for the gang war in which the bartender had been killed a couple of weeks earlier. They were headed for South Boston to pick up OâBrienâs ten-year-old daughter Marie. It was her birthday, and he had a cake for her in the backseat of the car. But OâBrien never made it back to South Boston. A Winter Hill hit car pulled up alongside his and Johnny Martorano opened fire with a machine gun, killing OâBrien and wounding DeMasi.
Casabielle asked Martorano about William OâBrien.
âI didnât know him. I was looking for the other guy that was with him.â
âSo William OâBrien, again, was a mistake?â
âIt could have been.â
âWe are talking about somebody that was possibly innocent.â
âHe was possibly guilty, too. They both showed up looking to buy guns to kill someone.â
The OâBrien hit was one of at least five murders committed by the Winter Hill Gang in 1973â74, when they were settling a score for the Mafia with a rogue organized-crime crew. Martorano explained how the other gang, which the Hill completely destroyed, had started the war by killing an LCN bookieââhis name was Paulie,â Martorano said, âI forget his last name.â
After the gang was wiped out, Johnny Martorano and Howie Winter went to the North End, and Jerry Angiulo, the Mafia underboss of Boston, gave them $25,000. But Johnny Martorano steadfastly maintained he never took money for killing people, not even from the Mafia and Jerry Angiulo.
âThat was like a donation from him,â Martorano said of the $25,000, âfor our help.â
Then Casabielle mentioned a 1981 murder he did in Oklahoma for John Callahan, whom Johnny would murder in Florida a year later. Callahan gave Martorano $50,000 after he traveled to Oklahoma to murder the owner of Callahanâs former company, who had to die because he suspected Callahan had been skimming money from his jai-alai frontons.
When he got the money, Johnny gave half of itâ$25,000âto his driver on the hit, fellow Winter Hill fugitive Joe McDonald. Then he split the remaining $25,000 with Stevie and Whitey back in Boston. So Johnny Martorano had banked a little over $8,000 for his nineteenth murder.
âWas that also a donation?â Casabielle asked.
âPositively.â
âWhat charity were they donating to?â
âTo Winter Hill.â
âAre you seriously telling this group of people that the money ⦠was a contribution to Winter Hill, the Winter Hill charity? Is that your testimony?â
âIt was a gift from him [Callahan]. He was so happy he didnât get indicted. Better than giving it to a lawyer, I guess.â
At that point Casabielle didnât even bother to point out that a year after accepting the $50,000, Martorano killed the guy who had given it to him. Later Johnny would tell the jury he âfelt lousyâ about having to âkill a guy who I had just killed a guy for.â
âIt was very distasteful,â he elaborated.
Instead, Casabielle stayed with the larger theme of the Winter Hill gang as a charity, returning to the money the Hill accepted for wiping out a small rival gang for the Mafia.
âAnd what good deeds did Winter Hill do other than kill people and feel good about it?â
âI