forget, but like they say, money canât buy love. The damage between me and April had been done.
April still couldnât look me in the eye. âThis isnât about your past.â
âWhat, then?â I said, my voice rising, as close to shouting as I came. âYouâve never had your ribs cracked, so you donât know how patronizing it is to say I
like
getting hurt. Did you pull that out of a college psych book? Or is it some
Dr. Phil
bullshit?â
A black African couple at the table beside us glanced over to see what the ruckus was. The moon-faced young woman in sunflower yellow was holding her dateâs hand, but he looked bored. The womanâs forlorn eyes begged us to show a better example of courtship.
âDo we really want to make this harder, Ten?â Aprilâs voice flowed like a yoga relaxation tape. She had already started moving on.
I thought of the old Richard Pryor routine where the calmer his woman got, the more he had a fit. I closed my eyes, forcing a deep breath. âI need to understand,â I said, opening my eyes. The lights stabbed my sudden headache. âWe were fine before, and now weâre not? What changed?â
April stared at her plate of half-eaten food. Our talk should have waited until dessert.
âIâve really been praying about this, because I started writing you letters and couldnât find the words. Thereâs a quality you haveâriding the chaos wave, seeing where it takes you. Itâs so beautiful and free and brave, just like you. Itâs the first thing that attracted me to your spirit. But now . . .â She didnât finish. When April first met me, I was a suspect in Serenaâs death; Iâd been a vote against her better judgment from day one.
April went on. âSome people can handle itâI
know
youâll find someone who canâbut I canât anymore. I canât sit around worrying about whether youâre going to get killed, or if youâll have to kill somebody. I canât live that wayâor raise our kids that way.â
I was about to promise April that I would never take another case, but the phrase
our kids
nearly made me choke on my bread. I tried to recover before she noticed, but I was too late. April gave me a resigned, heartbroken glance she tried to hide by drinking the last of her wine.
âWe have kids?â I said. I felt like Rip Van Hardwick. Had I missed something?
âIn two years Iâll be thirty, Ten. I want to be headed somewhere.â
I donât know how guys feel when theyâre ready to discuss marriage and kids, but I wasnât there yet. I was too tired to keep talking, so I should have kept my mouth shutâbut I thought I knew exactly what to say. What every woman wants to hear.
âAll I know is . . . ,â I said, pausing for effect. âI love you, Alice.â
For the first few seconds, I was confused by the horror on Aprilâs face.
You called her ALICE,
my memory whispered, and my insides shriveled.
âShit,â I said, honestly shocked. âJesus.â
Blasphemy was just for good measure, since April was a church girl. My words were gibberish to me, as if someone had hijacked my mouth. I couldnât think of an apology worthy of the transgression. I suppose my faux pas could have been worse. We could have been in bed.
Thereâs no good way to call your girlfriend by the wrong nameâbut Alice was a former client from my working days. She was one of my steadiest clients for years, despite an age difference that made her old enough to be my motherâolder, really. When she died, she left me her house, and Iâd been living there ever since. Iâd insisted to April that Iâd kept the house only out of convenience; it was worth $2 million even in a recession.
The past was the past, I had promised April. But it wasnât. It never was.
âI canât do this anymore,â April