the dim figure of Judge Tavister halted on the sidewalk in the deep shade of the roadside trees. The Judge came out to the road and called quietly, âFrank,â and Frank kneed his sorrel over to the edge of the street.
Judge Tavister was carrying his hat; in the almost unbroken darkness, Frank could not see the expression on his face.
âWhy did you ask that question about Rob?â Judge Tavister asked him.
âSomebody said Hannan isnât sure Robâs death was an accident.â
âWhat else did somebody say?â
Frank hesitated, reluctant to say this. âThat Hannan might suspect me of his murder.â
There was a long silence, and then Judge Tavister said, âFrank, what did you and Rob have that last quarrel about?â
âMy general uselessness,â Frank said tonelessly. âHe wanted me to work under Jess until I knew Saberâs business. I already knew it, and I wouldnât stay around him.â He paused, groping for words, and then said wanly, âOne thing led to another.â
âFists?â
âNo,â Frank said quickly. âHe hit me, and I let him.â He was remembering now. âHe said he was sorry heâd ever gone near the wagon train and found me. Said he was sorry the Utes didnât get me along with my folks. He said they must have known Iâd do more damage to the whites than fifty Indians, and thatâs why they let me live. He saidââ He hesitated.
âYes?â Judge Tavister prompted mildly.
Frank shifted in the saddle and said in a dull matter-of-fact voice: âHe said before he buried my mother he looked for a wedding ring and couldnât find it. She wore other rings, but no wedding ring. He said she looked as if she came out of a Houseâa cheap House.â
âAh,â Judge Tavister said, a faint disgust in his voice. âDoes Hannan have to know he said that?â
âHe knows it,â Frank said shortly. âRob said it in the bunk-house in front of the whole crew. I left then.â
There was an unrunning silence, and then Judge Tavister said gently, âWhy didnât you stay away, Frank?â
âCarrie,â Frank answered promptly.
âThatâs the reason you should have,â Judge Tavister said softly.
âThatâs the way youâve felt all along, isnât it, Judge?â
âNo man likes to see his child unhappy,â the Judge said quietly. âHeâll change it if he can.â
âYou canât.â
âYouâll have a lot of offers for Saber,â Judge Tavister went on. âThat always happens when a man dies. Take the best offer and get out. This is a big countryâas I think youâve proved to yourself.â
âAnd run away once more,â Frank murmured.
âYes. From what youâre bound to hurt.â
Frank tried to see Judge Tavisterâs face in the darkness and could not. He said slowly, âIf I hurt her again, Iâll go.â
âWhat if you canât help but hurt her again?â
Frank scowled, turning this over in his mind, making many things of it. âSpeak plainer, Judge.â
âAll right, what if Hannan decides rightly or wrongly that you murdered Rob. It could happen. Youâve got a reputation around here for being good-natured, good-looking and good-for-nothing, Frank, and people will envy you getting Saber. What if you wait it out in jail for a trial? The verdict doesnât matter. What about Carrie then?â
There was, Frank saw, a bitter truth in all this, and yet there was something else too that the Judge didnât see. âIf I sell Saber and drift, thatâs admitting Iâm afraid of what Hannan will turn up. Itâs admitting Iâm not worth much.â
âIâm not interested in it.â
âEven if Iâm innocent?â
Judge Tavister was silent a long, long moment, as if he were searching his mind for the