that the great man had expired porking someone?â
âOh, God, no! I just did my usual dog and pony about the evolution of the M.E.âs office, and at the part where I say that one of the problems of the job is doing autopsies of notable people, I may have mentioned him. Heâd died a couple of days before the presentation.â
âBut no death in the saddle?â
âOf course not!â
âWise. I expect we can corral enough distinguished physicians who were at the meeting to confirm it. In fact, when shown false, the charge is so infamous that itâll help with damages.â
Selig suddenly realized the import of this remark. âYouâre taking the case?â
âOh, yeah,â said Karp. âYouâll make an appointment, and weâll go over this stuff line by line.â
Karp shifted his swivel chair so that it faced the window and fell silent. He seemed deep in thought. After a minute or so, Selig cleared his throat and asked, âSoâyou think we have a good case?â
âOh, no question. Iâm a little rusty on employment law, but Iâm certain that a public official canât be fired for cause without some sort of hearing.â
âThe Mayor claims IâmâI was âa political appointee serving at his pleasure.â
Karp shook his head dismissively. âThatâs something weâll duke out. Even if they could fire you, Iâm almost sure they canât fire you for cause without giving you a hearing. Itâs not a Roth case. God, I canât believe I remembered that!â
âWhoâs Roth?â
âTeacher at Wisconsin, early seventies. Untenured. The school didnât renew his contract, and he sued. He claimed that they didnât renew because heâd pissed off the university authorities by criticizing the administration. Defendants came back with the argument that they didnât have to give any reason at all for not renewing, and the Supreme Court agreed.â
âThis is good for us?â
âYeah. The Supremes decided he didnât have what they call a property interest in his job, because they didnât fire him, they just declined to rehire him. You did have such an interest. Also, and probably more significantly for our purposes, when they declined to rehire Roth, they made no statement that would impugn his good name and prevent him from getting a job elsewhere. And from what you tell me, the press conference and all, thatâs very far from your case. They canned you for cause, and went public that they thought you were a bum. They canât do that, not without giving you the right of rebuttal. We can work a little deprivation of liberty action in here too.â
To Seligâs questioning look Karp added, âLiberty. Under Fourteenth Amendment case law, liberty includes the right to seek your customary employment. By maligning you without due process, theyâve limited your liberty in that way.â Karp stared out the window again.
âWhat are you thinking?â asked Selig when the waiting became too much for him.
Karp spun his chair slowly around until he faced Selig. âWhat Iâm thinking is, why? Bloom doesnât like to make waves. He made plenty over you. And he must have used some pretty big chips with the Mayor to get you out of the C.M.E.âs slot.â
âNaomi said itâs because heâs a controlling asshole.â
âThatâs true enough, but â¦ââKarp flipped the copies of the complaint letters on his deskââthis crap, this snails nonsense, isnât enough to warrant the hatchet job Bloom did on you.â
âThe reasonâs important?â
âOh, yeah. I think in a way itâs the key to the case. Not the case weâll argue in court, necessarily.â
Karp fell again into a silent study, and Selig, starting to become irritated with what seemed to him vagueness, changed the