know if I would have done that. I fell out of one of those trees once,â he said to me.
Papa said nothing.
âDo you like children?â asked Cassie, staring at Grandfather.
Grandfather took a spoonful of soup.
âDo you? Like children?â asked Cassie again.
Sarah reached out her hand and put it on Cassieâs arm to stop her talk.
âDonât know many,â said Grandfather.
âDo you like the ones you know?â
âNo,â said Grandfather.
Cassie was surprised at Grandfatherâs answer. Her mouth fell open.
âBut what about Papa?â asked Cassie. âDid you like Papa when he was little?â
âCassie! Eat,â said Papa.
âBut . . .â
âHush,â said Sarah.
Cassie was quiet for a moment. Then she looked at Grandfather.
âYou are not a nice man,â she said.
âNow, I told you that,â said Grandfather.
No one spoke for the rest of the meal. Even Cassie was quiet. Lottie and Nick watched us, waiting for talk. But there was no talk.
Â
âGood night, Grandfather.â
I stood in the doorway of his bedroom. His oil lamp was burning. Grandfather stood by the window looking out.
âThereâs a moon,â he said.
I went over and saw the moonlight on the barn, the meadows, the road going to town.
âI watched a lot of moons from this room,â said Grandfather.
âYou must have missed the farm,â I said.
Grandfather was silent.
âYou can read Annaâs journals,â I said. âThere on the table. You can read all about the farm. And about us. While you were gone.â
Grandfather didnât turn around.
I picked up one of Annaâs journals and opened it. I began to read to Grandfather.
ââPapa married Sarah on a summer day. There were no clouds in the sky, and Papa picked Sarah up in his arms and whirled her around and around, her white dress and veil surrounding them like the summer wind. Caleb was so excited and happy, he burst into tears.
ââEverybody was happy.ââ
There was silence, but Grandfather was looking at me.
âI did cry, I remember,â I said. âAnd I was happy.â
âGood night, Caleb,â he said finally. âClose the door behind you.â
Just before I closed the door, Seal crept into Grandfatherâs room and jumped up onto his bed.
Â
Grandfather hasnât opened Annaâs journals. He hasnât read mine. He doesnât talk to Papa. Only to Sarah, who makes him talk to her. Sometimes to Cassie and me.
Iâm glad Grandfather came.
But I donât like the silence.
6
I didnât have to tell Sarah about Grandfatherâs pills after all. It was the dogs, Lottie really, who showed her in the end, and Grandfather running after Lottie all over the house. All that noise. The dogs.
Â
Â
T here was no school for the next few days. The cold was hard for the horses and children. I would have liked it any other time, staying home. But not in this house. Not with Papa and Grandfather passing each other without talking, the only sounds in the house the clicking of Sarahâs knitting needles, Cassieâs chattering, Min batting a marble across the floor. Two times I heard Sarah and Papaâs voices, sharp and soft at the same time, behind their closed bedroom door. Once Papa had burst out of the room, brushing past me in the hallway. He had stayed in the barn most of the day.
âWhy wonât they talk to each other?â I whispered to Sarah.
âThey are stubborn, Caleb.â
âBut they are family,â I said.
âI know. Thatâs what makes it so hard.â
âCanât you do something? Canât you make Papaââ
âCaleb,â Sarah interrupted me. âYour papa has to do this himself.â
âI donât know, Sarah. Papaâs angry. Will he hurt Grandfather?â
Sarahâs look changed and she put her arms around