âThat he knew what was best?â
Her huge eyes fixed on mine. âNo,â she said slowly, a trace of defiance in her voice. âI loved her. I would have taken good care of her, no matter how hard it was.â
I said nothing, letting her savor this new perspective. âPerhaps he was the one who acted badly, then,â I suggested after a moment.
I could see her turning this idea over in her mind. I didnât expect a reply; I had only wanted to plant the possibility. I glanced around the room, the same room that had seemed so barren just moments before, and felt the seeping warmth of accomplishment. Perhaps the morning hadnât been a complete disaster after all.
She continued gazing into the distance, apparently lost in thought.
I touched her arm. âEliza?â
She swiveled toward me. âIâm going to do it. Tomorrow.â
âDo what?â
âAsk Dr. Hauptfuhrer.â She stood. âItâs her birthday in two days, on January 8. Wouldnât it be wonderful if, this time, I knew where she was?â
I rose beside her. âYou realize he may not have kept track of her. And even if he has, he probably wonât tell you.â
âHe might,â she said, smoothing her skirt front with her palms. âIf I insist.â
The notion of this unassuming woman insisting on anything was so incongruous that I couldnât help smiling. âElizaâ¦â
âI have to try,â she said, her cheeks flushing. âI owe her that.â
I hesitated, wondering whether I should attempt to dissuade her. But before I could say anything more, she had picked up her coat and started for the door.
At the partitionâs splintering edge, she stopped. âIâm going to telephone him as soon as I get home, to tell him that Iâm coming. That way, I wonât lose my nerve.â She smiled hesitantly. âWill you wish me luck?â
Again I was struck by how innocentâand how very vulnerableâshe appeared. âGood luck, Eliza.â
Her smile brightened, and then she turned and vanished around the corner.
She wasnât gone two seconds before the professorâs words started circling in my head: The therapistâs extraordinary power within the therapeutic relationship must be carefully exercised; the impact of his words and behavior on the patient cannot be overestimatedâ¦
I was aware, of course, that Elizaâs story had affected me on a personal level, and in more ways than one. But I didnât believe I had allowed this to influence my conduct. After all, it was she, not I, who had suggested questioning the doctor. And looking at it objectively, I couldnât say that this was an inappropriate course of action. Sheâd been so riddled with guilt all these years that sheâd never been able to speak up for herself or even acknowledge her tremendous loss. Asserting herself with Dr. Hauptfuhrer had to be a move in the right direction. She needed to regain faith in herself, to learn to respect her own rights, and to recognize the injury that had been done to her before she could move on with her life.
I returned to my desk to gather my things. In all likelihood, the doctor would be either unwilling or unable to disclose her daughterâs current whereabouts, so there was little chance for complications on that score, whatever my feelings on the subject might be. Eliza would be disappointed, of courseâbut in the process of asking, sheâd be taking her first step toward recovery. And that, I told myself as I pulled on my coat, was all her psychotherapist could ask for.
Chapter Two
I emerged from the parish house to find that the sky had clouded over and a few light snowflakes were falling. Pulling up my collar, I retraced my steps north through the bustle of Yorkville and west across Ninety-Second Street toward home. By the time I reached my block, the snow was coming down steadily, stirred by gusts off