deconstructing Penn State football. He was going to demand more, inspire more, discipline more. He was going to discard some philosophies that no longer worked and adopt a few new ones.
âYou forget to do the things that got you there,â he would explain. âYou stop paying attention to the tiny details. Now Iâve got to get back to those things. Itâs like starting over. Iâve got to prove a couple of things and I think itâs going to be interesting to see if I can do it.â
His team had gotten its first glimpse of the changes a month earlier.
The 2003 Nittany Lions had been as bad off the field as on it. Inside the program, there was a hope that with the end of that dreadful season might come an end to the extracurricular trouble as well. Paterno certainly intended that to be the case.
Then, sometime around 4:00 A . M . on February 7, near the end of the Alpha Phi Alpha fraternityâs âBlack Iceâ dance and skate party at Penn Stateâs Greenburg Ice Pavilion, a fight broke out. Like a sprawling barroom brawl from an old Western, it went on for more than ten minutes and eventually involved fifteen to twenty people. Among them were three key players, defensive linemen Matthew Rice and Ed Johnson and quarterback/wide receiver Michael Robinson.
Robinson, the central ingredient in Paternoâs football plans for the upcoming season, had been knocked into the rinkâs glass trophy case during the fight. The junior was cut so badly behind his left ear that he needed twenty-four stitches to close the wound. No charges were ever filed, but Paterno suspended Johnson and Rice for summer practice. Robinson, whose role in the melee the coach deemed ânot as aggressive,â was put on probation.
âThey were wrong. They were in a fight,â Paterno told reporters. âWeâve taken care of it.â
That sentiment was for public consumption. Privately, Paterno fumed. He quickly summoned his team to a meeting. He told them he wouldnât put up with that kind of thing this season. They were going to discover a lot of changes when they returned to the field the following month. Either theyâd work harder and behave better or theywouldnât be running out of the Beaver Stadium tunnel with him next September 4 for the season-opening game with Akron.
âHe told us, âThatâs it,â â said senior quarterback Zack Mills. â âNext incident, youâre gone.â He was tired of it happening every other week. Heâs serious. . . . The margin for error is gone.â
All rules would be strictly enforced. No long hair, cornrows, beards, or mustaches. Players struggling in class or late for meetings would jeopardize their playing time.
The athletes, many of whom had been so dismayed by the 3â9 season that they were considering transfers, welcomed the new spark they saw in their old coach.
âWe needed Joe to put us in our place,â said tight end Isaac Smolko.
So even though, at this first spring workout, the playersâ outfits were relatively casualânavy-blue shorts, white T-shirts, spikes, and helmetsâthe atmosphere was surprisingly intense for March.
âHe wants to coach like he coached in the past, when people were scared of him,â said Levi Brown, an offensive tackle. âI donât think people have been scared of him lately.â
Players had been accustomed to Paternoâs whiny complaints and his obsession with details. Many of them, though, had begun to tune him out. While they respected his accomplishments, and were in awe of his reputation, they couldnât help but occasionally see him as a grandfatherly figure, a hopelessly outdated old man who sputtered furiouslyâcomically sometimes to themâat their mistakes and constantly referenced long-gone players and coaches.
Now, with his postbrawl crackdown and his vow of zero tolerance, their views began to