everything, who brandishes guns, willing to use them. . . .
"You've changed," I finally say, puncturing the stillness.
"How?"
"You're just . . . different now."
His finger traces the rim of the glass, agitating the wine. "Be more specific."
"I don't know. You're not. . . . You don't seem like you, anymore."
"I thought every girl wanted the bad guy," he says, taking a swig.
"You're not a bad guy," I tell him.
"What am I, then? Or better yet, what, exactly, am I supposed to be?"
My shoulders lift, a quiet shrug. "I don't know. Carter . Carter Fleming ."
"What does that even mean?" he asks.
"It means what it means. This isn't. . . . It's not you ."
"Why? Because I'm a Fleming? Because we're loaded? No cares? No worries?"
The fire warms my bare skin, dries my eyes. "That's not what I meant."
"But it's true. We have our whole lives set up for us."
My cheeks prickle with the heat of embarrassment.
The accident—the fight we had .
"I'm sorry. I was angry. I shouldn't have said . . ."
"You were right, though."
"No, I was wrong. I should've never dragged you into this. Your life was perfect before you met me."
"You didn't drag me into this. And I didn't start living until I met you."
"This isn't living ," I argue, voice rising. "Not hiding in the mountains. Not running from demons. You should be in school right now. Having fun ."
"That's not what I want. If I go to college, if I work for my dad, if I become just like him, it's over. I mean, what difference would I make? In a hundred years, who would even care?"
The flames snap, sparks revolting as they mount the sky.
"I care." I slide out of the dark cardigan and set it aside. The firelight dances with the images on my arm.
"I want to be more than a Fleming," he says, ignoring me. "I want a chance to make my own difference, apart from them."
He takes my hand in his and turns my arm over, examining the flowers and vines, the contrasting colors, patterns. And I hate that I don't know what he's thinking, what he sees when he looks at me. We broke up what feels like forever ago—like yesterday. I fell for my Guardian—the one who was supposed to protect me—and now he's gone. I've lost everything, and it's all my fault. If I would've been better. . . . If I would've fought harder. . . . And here he is, caught in the middle of it all. I swallow back contempt for Viola. The Council. Myself.
"It's hideous. I hate it."
"It's beautiful," he replies.
"It's like I sold my soul."
"We sell our soul every day, Gee. Little by little."
I pull my arm away from him, take another quick sip of wine. Carter stares ahead, vacant eyes reflecting the firelight, lost. A log crumbles apart, cracking and popping as it settles.
"I haven't given you your birthday present," he finally says.
"This is enough, Carter. I can't pay you back for any of this—everything you've done for me."
"I haven't asked you to. And I won't. I promised." He clears his throat, a somber frown deepening his features.
"The thing is . . . I got you something for your birthday, and I need to give it to you."
His hand slips inside his pants pocket and removes a tiny black jewelry box.
"What is it?" I ask, hesitating.
He refuses to meet my gaze, handing it to me. "Open it."
I slowly lift the cover.
Inside, nestled between velvet folds—a ring.
The stone is round, a subtle shade of blue, double band encrusted with tiny, diamond-like stones that sparkle in the firelight.
I exhale a quick gasp. "Oh My God. Carter! This is beautiful!"
"It reminded me of you," he explains, with a trace of sadness too hard to ignore.
"It's like . . . water. A tropical ocean. Is it a topaz?"
"Something like that."
I study the ring, turning it this way then that, light springing from every angle. I imagine what it would look like on my finger. It must've cost a small fortune. "I can't accept this," I say, handing it back to him.
"I knew you were going to say that. And I also know that, not only can you not accept