It came out more loudly than Iâd expected.
Jeff looked nervously toward the door and whispered, âShhh. Take it easy, Ben. He didnât mean to sink it.â
âI canât believe it,â I said, whispering now, too. âWhat if he gets caught?â
âHeâs not going to get caught.â Jeff looked at me earnestly, really believing what he was saying.
âHow do you know? The police are looking for the person who did it!â
Jeff shrugged. âNobody saw him.â
âBut why did he do it?â I asked.
Jeff leaned toward me and said in a hushed voice, âYou know Jen, Donnyâs girlfriend?â
I nodded. Everybody knew Jen and Donny.
âWell, the kid who was driving the car was hitting on Jen at South Beach the other day, trying to impress her with his fancy car, get her to go for a ride and stuff. So Donny was just, you know, teaching him a lesson.â
âGeez,â I said, imagining the whole scene. Donny was touchy about the Tomahawk, but that was nothing compared to how he was about Jen. No kid from the island would be braveâor stupidâenough to flirt with Jen since sheâd started going out with Donny. Not that Donny went around threatening people or anything like that, but still, you didnât want Donny mad at you. You just never knew what he might do.
âSo the kid had it coming,â Jeff went on. âMaybe heâll tell his friends they canât just come here and throw their money around and treat us like dirt.â
Treat us like dirt? What had the kid ever done to Jeff? I wondered. Then it hit me: the kid! âWhere is the kid, anyway?â I asked.
Jeff shrugged again. âDonât know. I donât think anybody knows.â
âNot even Donny?â
âNope. Donny left after he pushed the car in, and he never saw the kid again after that.â
âAnd the kid just let Donny push his car in the water?â
âNo. He was out on the beach, meeting some other kids.â
It was pretty clear that Jeff was taking Donnyâs side completely. He said, âYouâre not going to tell, are you?â
Tell? I hadnât thought that far ahead. When I didnât answer immediately, Jeff said, â Ben . You canât tell.â He looked at me incredulously and urged, âCome on , Ben. Itâs not like he did it to one of our cars, like Chickâs or your momâs or something. It belonged to one of them .â
âThatâs why youâre covering for him?â
âWell, yeah. What do I care about that rich little snot or his car? Donnyâs my friend .â
I couldnât even talk. My thoughts were too jumbled up, and Jeff seemed so sure.
âAnd youâre my friend,â he said. Then he added, âRight?â
âWell, duh.â
He smiled, spreading his hands wide, as if that settled that.
I felt trapped in Jeffâs small, cluttered bedroom. I couldnât breathe. Desperate to get away, I glanced at the clock. To my relief, it was almost nine-thirty. âLook, I really gotta go,â I said, standing up. âYou know how Mom is.â
âYeah,â said Jeff. âOkay.â Then, looking worried, he said, âYouâre not mad or anything?â
Mad? I didnât know what I was, but I wasnât mad at Jeff. I just needed time to think things over. âNo,â I said.
âGood,â he answered, and flashed me his old smile.
I raced down the stairs, said a quick good-bye to the Mannings, and stepped out into the driveway. There was a light coming from the garage. Great. The last thing I wanted to do was run into Donny again. I crept toward my bike, trying not to let the gravel crunch beneath my feet.
âLeaving, Ben?â Donny seemed to materialize out of nowhere. Suddenly he was standing between my bike and me. His voice was casual and light, as usual.
âYeah,â I said, âand Iâve got to