Carson cut him off. âAny size limb you think you can handle,â he said. âThen we just beat the hell outta each other with âem till one of us has had enough. Is that simple enough?â
That brought a grin to Varnerâs face. âFair enough,â he said. âLetâs get at it.â With the size and strength advantage he knew he held over the younger man, he felt sure he could make short work of it. âIf thatâs the way you wanna get your ass busted, hell, fine by me.â
By this time, the whole crew was aware of the confrontation building up between the camp strongman and the new hand, so they followed the two adversaries to the trees on the bank. Even those watching the herd were staying close to the creek, hoping not to miss what promised to be a short and brutal beating. Rufus brought a hand ax with him for each man to use to cut his weapon, and Varner eagerly grabbed it and went to work on a cottonwood limb about the size of his upper arm. When it crashed to the ground, he chopped it off to a length of about five feet. Satisfied with his choice, he tossed the ax over to land at Carsonâs feet, then hefted the sturdy section of limb confidently.
âDamn, Varner,â Marvin remarked facetiously. âYou reckon thatâs big enough? You coulda saved yourself some trouble and picked up that log lyinâ over yonder.â
Marvinâs remark pleased the gloating bully. âI reckon I coulda handled it, but I didnât need it for this little job.â He turned to Carson then and goaded, âHurry up, Pig. I ainât got all day.â
Ignoring Varnerâs taunting, Carson picked up the ax and fashioned his weapon from the same limb. Moving out toward the smaller end, he chopped off a section that was about the thickness of a broom handle at the butt end and tapered off to the size of a pencil after a length of around eight feet. He trimmed off the smaller branches, then tested the feel of it. Satisfied, he said he was ready to start.
Varner laughed at the size of Carsonâs weapon and asked, âYou sure you can lift that?â
âWhat about the rules?â Rufus asked. âI ainât never heard of a tree limb fight.â
âRules?â Varner roared. âWe donât need no rules. When he canât get up no more, then itâs over. Thatâs all the rules we need.â
âThat all right with you, Carson?â Rufus asked.
âI reckon,â he replied. âJust stand back a little and give us room.â The few men standing around them backed up a little. Carson knew he needed room to move. Varner was big and powerful, but Carson was sure he was quicker than the lumbering bully, and he knew that was his best defense against him. He had counted on Varner to pick a sizable length of timber, and the big man had not disappointed him. His plan was to wear him down to the point where the heavy limb became too cumbersome to wield with any degree of effectiveness.
âGo to it,â Rufus signaled.
As Carson expected, Varner immediately charged like an angry bull, the heavy limb raised in both hands over his head. Carson held his ground until Varner was almost upon him, and then he easily sidestepped him and popped him across his cheek with his cottonwood whip, leaving a stinging welt. Varner yelped in surprise, almost dropping his cumbersome weapon when he grabbed his cheek with one of his hands. He yelped again when seconds later Carson popped him several times around his head and neck while he was groping to regain a position to attack again. Like a man fighting a grizzly, Carson backed slowly in the face of Varnerâs advance. With his longer whiplike weapon, he was able to deliver a steady series of stinging blows while moving quickly enough to frustrate Varnerâs efforts to get in close enough to use his bludgeon. Varner tried to grab the stinging whip, but he found that he could not effectively