children being carried by their fathers long after their mothers had lost the strength. Girls giving perfunctory, embarrassed pecks to their fathersâ cheeks at the school gates. Kids asking forâand receivingâwads of notes from their fatherâs wallets, together with a promise not to tell your mother . Endearments like âprincessâ and âhoney.â Gestures and generosities somehow more special from a father than from a mother.
When I was eight I spent a week with my friend Phyllis at her grandmotherâs summer home. On the Saturday night, Phyllisâs dad was instructed by her mother to âwear us out.â He bustled us onto the huge green lawn and asked us to line up. From the way Phyllisâs sister and brother started to giggle, theyâd clearly played this game before. I couldnât see a ball or a Frisbee, so when he said âGo!â I remained where I was, even after the others scampered off in different directions. A split second later, I was flying.
âGotcha!â Phyllisâs dad said, tossing me high into the air. His voice was animated. âThat was too easy. What am I going to do with her, kids?â
Phyllis shouted out from the tree branch on which she sat with her sister. âTickle her, Dad.â She laughed hysterically. âYou have to tickle her.â
âDeath by tickling, eh?â He pinned me to the grass and observed me with mock seriousness. âIâm not sure Grace is ticklish. Are you, Grace?â
âYes,â I said, already feeling giddy. âI am.â
He waggled his fingers in the air, then brought them down on my stomach, my sides, my neck. Giggles rippled through me until my stomach ached and I thought Iâd explode. I rolled around until my pajamas were covered in grass stains. Iâd never experienced a greater feeling of content, not before or after.
Eventually he let me go and went after the others. They sprinted away squealing, climbing trees and tucking themselves into small cavities under the house. I didnât understand. Were they trying to avoid the tickling and the throwing? If it were my Dad, I would have just lain there, a sitting duck to his tickling hands.
No, Neva didnât realize what she was doing by keeping her babyâs father a secret. She had a doting father. Sheâd had shoulder rides and tickling and nicknames. She would have a Papa for her children one day and, if she chose it, she would be walked down the aisle.
I knew what her baby would be missing out on. And I wasnât going to let it happen.
Â
3
Floss
It was the same nightmare Iâd had for sixty years. There were different versions, but they were fundamentally the same: I go into my babyâs room or pick up my little girl from school and sheâs not there. Initially I stay calm; there must be some kind of explanation. Sheâs rolled under the bed. Sheâs hiding. Itâs someone elseâs turn to pick her up. But my neck already feels sweaty and I canât hear my thoughts too well past the sound of my thundering heart. Itâs not long before the hysteria starts. I start thrashing around the nursery or school parking lot, searching for a glimpse of that soft red hair or freckles. Instead I see another face. The face that is synonymous with the end of life as I know it. The end of life with my daughter.
I jerked upward into darkness, my fingers twisted in the bedcovers. Lil was by my side, her warm body a stark contrast to my chilling dream. I lay down again, mimicking her slow breathsâin out, in outâuntil my heart began to slow. It felt like déjà vu. The situations werenât exactly the same, but the similarities were striking. Neva was going to be a single mother. The father of her child remained under a shroud of secrecy. And if her reasons for this were anything like my own, well ⦠that was what terrified me.
I needed to go to sleep. But when I