studied the reaction of Judge Cynthia Baker-Kline. Because this was a request for a preliminary injunction that hinged primarily on legal issues, as opposed to factual determinations, there would be no jury in the box. Her Honor would be the sole decision maker. And Her Honor was not giving off good vibes.
Jasmine had heard her law school professors say you could sell tickets to any trial involving Judge Baker-Kline. Feared by most, the judge that lawyers called âIchabodâ combined a hair-trigger temper with a razor-sharp tongue that could slice up even seasoned litigators. She had a face that was all angles and bonesâsunken eyes and a jutting jaw. Her reading glasses had crawled down her Wicked-Witch-of-the-West nose as the hearing progressed and were now hovering at the very end of that precipice, defying the laws of physics as they balanced there, mesmerizing Jasmine, who found herself wondering how they stayed.
Jasmine split her attention between the glasses and the telltale vein on the right side of Ichabodâs neck that pulsed visibly when she got upset, like a barometer of her anger and angst, a warning to smart lawyers that it was time to change the subject. As Ichabod listened to the mayorâs testimony, the vein pulsed in and out, in and out. Quickly. Grotesquely.
And Ichabod was scowling.
The mayor survived nearly an hour of pointed questions by Vince Harrod, attorney for the ACLU, and then a feeble attempt by the townâs attorney to rehabilitate his testimony. Just when it looked like he might escape, the judge herself started in. âWho owns the Possum town square?â she asked the witness.
âThe town does,â the mayor responded in his high-pitched voice. âBut Freewill Baptist Church maintains the manger scene.â
âDo you charge Freewill Baptist Church any rent for the portion of the square where the manger scene sits?â
âNo, maâam.â The mayor gave the townâs lawyer a do-something look, but the lawyer appeared not to notice.
The mayor was a small man with a round face and a big handlebar mustache. Jasmine remembered the night he had handed out keys to the town at a banquet honoring Jasmineâs state runner-up basketball team. Her teammates had dubbed him the âMunchkin Mayor,â based on his resemblance to the character in The Wizard of Oz .
âAnd where might you attend church, Mr. Frumpkin?â Ichabod leaned into the question, and the mayorâs eyes went wide.
âCan she do that?â Thomas whispered to Jasmine. Jasmine just nodded.
A few seconds of silence followed as if the Munchkin Mayor had just been exposed in some mortal sin.
âDo you understand the question?â Ichabod scowled.
âYes, Your Honor.â
âWell?â
âI attend Freewill Baptist Church of Possum.â
Ichabod made a check mark on her legal pad. She turned to Harrod. âThe town council resolution authorizing a manger scene in the Possum town square for the holiday seasonâwhat exhibit number was that?â
âExhibit 9, Your Honor.â
âPlease look at Exhibit 9,â Ichabod instructed Mayor Frumpkin, âand tell me what that resolution says about who will maintain this manger scene on behalf of the city.â
Bert Frumpkin pulled the exhibit out of the stack of papers in front of him, handling it carefully like the snake it had become. He took his time reading it, licking his lips a couple of times in the process.
âIt doesnât say anything?â he finally responded.
To Jasmine, the mayorâs answer sounded like a question, the way kids guess at an answer in class when they donât know, hoping the teacher might accept their humble offering.
âThen whose idea was it to delegate this responsibility to the good folks at Freewill Baptist Church?â
Frumpkin hesitated. âIâm not 100 percent sure.â
This brought a glare from Ichabod that lowered