Leeds this last week; some of the delegates are decamping here tomorrow for the lectures. I think Melissa would have loved to stage a full-scale convention, with all the delegates on-site, but the accommodation really isnât ready. So, weâre bussing people in for tomorrow . . .â
âWe?â Rina enquired.
Toby grinned at her. âGuilty,â he said. âNo, actually, I got dragged into this by David, thatâs Professor Franklin. Heâll be master of ceremonies tomorrow. I got to know him about eighteen months ago. Heâs written quite widely on the use of early photography and also what you could term magic tricks in a religious context. Heâs supervising Gail Perry, whoâll be our medium at the seance. Gail is a PhD student writing about the various quasi-scientific movements that sprang up in the North of England particularly, and it was her research that uncovered the strange events here in the winter of 1872. Thatâs what tomorrowâs reconstruction is all about. Hopefully without the subsequent insanity and violent death.â
He took a bite of his sandwich, and Rina glared at him, so obvious was his enjoyment in making them wait.
âOh, for goodnessâ sake,â Viv said. âThey had this seance one night â in fact, the anniversary is tomorrow, which is pretty good timing, donât you think? Theyâd had loads before, everyone seems to have been at it back then, but this was different. Everyone involved had spent Christmas and New Year together, and during that time theyâd invented a ghost.â
âInvented one?â Joy was amused. âWhy?â
âWell,â Toby butted in, taking his story back again. âIt actually prefigured a thing called the Philip experiment in Toronto about a hundred years later. A group of Canadian researchers under the direction of a Dr Owen and his wife got together and created a persona called Philip. Over several months they discussed who he might have been, decided he was a seventeenth-century English aristocrat with a string of mistresses.â
âNo, just one mistress. She was burned as a witch, they decided, which of course is terribly inaccurate,â Viv interrupted again.
âInaccurate?â Joy asked.
âWe hanged our witches,â Rina told her. âBurning was for heretics.â
âThatâs right.â Viv nodded enthusiastically. âThey did it different in Scotland, but in England it was the hangman who dealt with convicted witches.â
âAnyway,â Toby laughingly reasserted, âin essence, the modern group created Philip, but the Philip they invented and then tried to contact in the seance room behaved pretty much the same way as any other ghostly presence reported in the literature. The table they used was rapped on and moved and even performed on the television in front of the cameras. Of course, it could all be a bit of clever camera trickery and a lot of manipulationââ
âOr it could be that they accidentally stumbled on something real.â It was the first time Robin had contributed to the conversation. He blushed, Rina noticed, noting too that Viv reached out and grabbed his hand and glared at Toby as his laughter exploded.
âWeâre all entitled to our opinions,â Viv told their professor sternly.
âIâm not saying I believe that.â Robin was defensive. âJust that we should keep our minds open as well as our eyes.â
âWhich saying is, I believe, a direct quote from our dear David Franklin.â
Rina looked sharply at Toby, noting the hardening of his tone and the increased pressure of Vivâs hand on Robinâs. Ah, not so happy families, then, she thought.
âSo, youâre saying this Philip behaved as though he was real and not something theyâd made up?â Joy was intrigued.
âAppeared to, yes. Thereâs a lecture on it tomorrow. I think