to steal gasoline out of Zeke Parkerâs drum once. He had to go back for seconds.â
âToo greedy for his own good,â the deputy said with a chuckle.
Olivia recognized the man in handcuffs the moment she saw him. Dale Keller had been a troublemaker around Millerâs Creek for years. Heâd been in and out of jail since he was a teenager for almost every offense under the sun, but he was a born thief. With rationing for the war effort, Dale had been suspected of a number of thefts, stealing whatever he could get his hands on in order to sell it on the black market. Up until today, heâd been able to avoid getting caught.
âYou sons-a-bitches!â Dale shouted. âI didnât do nothinâ!â
âThatâs what Iâve been sayinâ,â Sylvester added; heâd been woken by all the commotion and was watching intently.
âLetâs get him in there,â John said, nodding toward the one remaining empty cell. âHeâll calm down soon enough.â
But then, just as they were a few feet from the open door, Dale suddenly lashed out with his foot and clipped Huck in the back of his leg. The deputy wobbled before eventually pitching over, letting go of the criminalâs arm as he fell. Olivia gasped; she was sure that Dale was going to get free. But any hopes he might have had about freedom were short-lived. Calmly but firmly, the sheriff grabbed hold of the manâs cuffed hands and lifted them up as he simultaneously pushed between Daleâs shoulder blades, forcing him down. The strain he created on the manâs joints was so painful that Dale cried out in agony. John walked him forward before giving him a shove, sending the thief sprawling onto the hard floor of the cell, his face landing with a thud. Before Dale could even turn around, Oliviaâs father had already pulled the door shut and locked it. Everything was over before it had really begun.
Sitting on his rump, Huck shook his head, clearly discouraged, his pride more wounded than his rear end. âSorry about that, boss,â he grumbled, accepting Johnâs hand and struggling back to his feet. âI feel like a fool letting that rat get the better of me.â
The sheriff waved it off. âDaleâs a handful,â he said. âI know that all too well. Heâs been fighting me ever since I caught up with him. You shouldâve seen me trying to wrestle him into handcuffs.â
Still plenty intoxicated, Sylvester had started cackling at the sight of Daleâs comeuppance; even the threatening way the thief was glaring at him wasnât enough to stop his laughter.
âYou best knock that off,â Huck cautioned. âOtherwise, Iâll put you both in the same cell. I donât reckon itâll be so funny then.â
The deputy must have sounded serious; the old drunkâs guffaws dwindled into a series of coughs before he fell silent.
Olivia stared at her father. John Marsten was just shy of fifty, his sandy blond hair touched with silver at the temples, the skin around his piercing blue eyes starting to become marred by wrinkles. Though he was lean, he was strong in build as well as stature, the sort of man who commanded a roomâs attention just by entering it. Even in situations like the one that had just happened, he never appeared ruffled, but calm and collected. Heâd been the law in Millerâs Creek since just after Olivia had been born, a fixture in town as familiar as the red and white pole outside the barbershop or the clock high above the bank. Much like the rest of the townsfolk, he had always made Olivia feel safe.
Hanging up the cell keys, John finally noticed his daughter. âOlivia,â he said, his face softening. âI didnât know you were here.â Looking back at Dale, he added, âIâm sorry you had to see that.â
âIâm fine,â she reassured him.
Glancing down at his watch,