âOkay. Well, cool. Iâll just tell Eli you made an emergency call and brought the police screaming down onto his business, and you can explain it all to him.â
I tried to shoot David an evil glare, but evil glares werenât in my repertoire. Plus I knew David well enough to know heâd never really tell our boss.
I stared at the scrap of paper with the license plate and other info written on it. âThat girl who came in,â I said. âSheâs a friend of mine. It has to be her.â
âShe was kidnapped,â David said.
âYeah. I havenât seen her in six years.â
âSo . . . what happened? I mean, back then. What went on? Was there an investigation and all that?â
âOh yeah. One minute she was there, outside the doors. Then someone must have lured her to his car, scooped her up . . . and thatâs it.â
âWow,â David said again, searching my eyes with his. Iâm not sure why.
âIt took a while to figure out that she was gone,â I said. âWhen I found her mom, she was only mad that Tara was hiding, at first. It mustâve been twenty or thirty minutes before we figured out something might be really wrong. So the search was just limited to the store, then the mall. I mean, by the timethe cops were actually involved, it had been hours. They looked for years. The whole thing was even on one of those missing persons shows. Abducted. I donât think itâs on anymore. . . .â
I only kept talking because I didnât like the way Davidâs expression had shifted. Like he wasnât really listening.
âIt must have really hurt you,â he said.
I guess he was listening after all. Except he was hearing things I wasnât saying. I didnât like it.
âIâm over it,â I said.
âReally,â David said, but it wasnât a question.
âReally,â I said, and turned back to start rewashing the sink. Just to have something to do other than look into his face.
â So over it that when a girl comes into the shop and reminds you of her, you write down the license plate of the car she got into and call 911?â
âIt was her, goddammit, it was Tara, and I just stood here and didnâtââ
I cut myself off. He wouldnât understand.
âHey, Pelly?â David said.
âWhat.â
âIâm sorry. Seriously.â
I ground my teeth for a few seconds, then finally grunted, âThanks.â
âSo what are you going toââ
âCustomers,â I said, pointing to the door just as a couple of business-exec types came walking in. âSlumming it,â as David liked to say, for a caffeine hit.
David gave me a look like the conversation wasnât over, but I knew it was. I knew it because I decided it. I didnât want to go into it anymore. I just wanted to be better. Normal. Like it never happened.
Except it did.
And now the only places I ever went anymore were less than a mile from home. Now my only friends were psychos like me or anonymous Internet denizens. Or, sort of, David. But not really.
I snapped my rubber band against my wrist.
Stop intrusive thoughts. Stop intrusive thoughts.
FOUR
âWatch!â my little brother, Jeffrey, said as soon as I opened the front door. âWatch what I can do, Pelly!â
I had picked up the nickname Pelly from Jeffrey. When he was littler, he couldnât make all the right syllables of Penelope. Tara and I both thought it was endlessly cute.
I didnât know what I thought of it anymore.
Jeffrey sat parked in front of our TV playing some game. I didnât recognize it beyond it being on regular rotation during his schoolâs winter break. Since Jeffrey wasnât insane, he got to go to regular school. Heâd never understand how lucky he was to be able to go without a complete psychological meltdown.
Iâd love to go back. Iâd