which she took a small bite.
When she had chewed it and swallowed, she said, âHe believes in good and evil.â
âOne of those,â I said.
âOne of those.â
âHe says thereâs no insanity defense.â
âHe got a shrink?â
âSchool psychologist.â
âYou talk to him?â
âNo.â
âWell, even if the shrink is good, and sometimes theyâre not,â Rita said, âoversimplified, an insanity defense is going to go something like this:
â Expert: Because of a flopp to the fanottim, the defendant suffers from irresistible compulsion.
â Cleary: How do you know he has a compulsion?
â Expert: Iâve interviewed him.
â Cleary: And he told you he had a compulsion.
â Expert: Yes.
â Cleary: How do you know itâs irresistible?
â Expert: He acted on it. He couldnât help himself.
â Cleary: So if somebody commits a crime, and claims compulsion, the commission is proof that the compulsion was irresistible?
â Expert: Well . . .â
I held up my hand.
âGot it,â I said.
âA good defense lawyer and a good expert, or maybe several, can shape this, make it work better than Iâve described,â Rita said. âBut thereâs no reason to think this guy is a good defense lawyer. If the kid is a credible witness on his own behalf, it would help.â
âI havenât seen him yet, either.â
âYou sound like youâre getting stonewalled,â Rita said.
âLocal police chief doesnât want me around. I figure thatâs because he botched the thing badly and doesnât want attention called.â
âSo why doesnât the kidâs lawyer want you around?â
âDoesnât want me screwing up the kidâs plea, if I had to guess.â
âWhich you do,â Rita said. âNot having anything in the way of facts.â
âHe doesnât want me talking to the kid,â I said.
âBethel County Jail?â
âYeah.â
âI know people out there, you need any help.â
âHealy can get me in there,â I said.
âIâm sure he can,â Rita said.
âYou talked to the parents yet?â
âNot yet.â
âThat might be interesting.â
I nodded.
âKnow a lawyer named Alex Taglio,â I said, âworks for Batson and Doyle?â
âAlex Taglio, yes. Used to be a prosecutor in Suffolk County before he decided to make money.â
âNot unlike others,â I said.
âI was a prosecutor in Norfolk County before I decided to make money. Thereâs a huge difference.â
âI can see that,â I said. âHe any good?â
âYes. Alex is a good lawyer. Works hard. Whoâs he represent?â
âThe other kid,â I said, âWendell Grant.â
âHe and Leeland get along?â Rita said.
âLeeland indicated no,â I said.
âPerfect,â Rita said. âThey being tried separately?â
âI donât know,â I said.
âProbably not. Same crime. Whatâs Grantâs defense?â
âDonât know yet,â I said.
âWhat do you think of Grandma?â
âSmart,â I said. âTough.â
âNot old and losing her grip?â
âNo. Leeland sort of implied that, but I donât believe him. She seemed right there when I talked with her.â
âWhy would the parents want to discourage an attempt to find their son innocent of multiple murder charges?â
âDonât know,â I said.
âYou donât know shit,â Rita said, âdo you?â
âNo,â I said. âBut itâs okay, Iâm used to it.â
8
I T HAD BEEN a rainy summer, and it was raining again. It was a good late-summer rain, warm, no wind, but not so hard that it overcame your defenses. I wished I was walking in it, holding Susanâs hand. Susan