though he wasnât sure his ears had heard what theyâd heard. The chime of the front door alerted them of Barbaraâs arrival, and Chris closed the door to Mitchellâs office and then sat in the chair directly across from his desk. He didnât speak, but his eyes were full of questions. In a matter of seconds, Mitchell answered the most dominant one.
âVirtue is . . . Virtue
was
my wife.â
Losing complete interest in the coffee heâd just been enjoying, Chris placed the still-full cup on his partnerâs desk and then pushed it to the side. âYour
what
?â
âMy wife. The woman who walked in the restaurant used to be my wife. That was the first time Iâd seen her since I struck her for the second time during one of my drunken rages.â
Chris was still having trouble processing Mitchellâs first few words. âYou have a wife?â
âHad,â Mitchell corrected.
âHave . . . had . . . whatever.â Chris shrugged. âHow, in three years, have I not known that you were once married?â
âYou never asked.â Mitchell knew that the answer wasnât a valid one, but he also knew that Chris wouldnât presshim to give a more detailed one. Instead, Chris changed the question and proposed a new one.
âHow long had it been since youâd seen her?â
âWeâd just gotten married less than a year before my grandparents died, so I quickly became a different man than the man she married. Virtue hung in with me for almost three years, which was probably more than most women would have. But when the drinking started and then got out of control to the point where I was taking my frustrations out on her, she left. That terrified look that she had on her face at Bobâs was the same look of horror that she had the first time I hit her. I thought Iâd lost her then because she stormed out of the house, leaving me there to wallow in self-pity all by myself. But when I woke up the next morning, she was right there beside me in the bed. She came back.â
âAnd you hit her again?â Chris was clearly fascinated by this story that heâd never heard before.
Mitchell nodded, surprised at how easy it was for him to share the most shameful part of his life with his friend. Heâd held it inside himself for so long that heâd not noticed that it was not only a secret, but a burden. Telling Chris about it felt liberating.
âIt must have been pretty bad the second time around for her to leave permanently,â Chris said after Mitchell quietly drifted back in time.
âTwo weeks later I hit her twice as hard as the first time,â Mitchell explained. He shook his head in regret as he recalled the day it happened. âShe hadnât done anything wrong. Every day she was going to work and trying to pay the bills that I couldnât because of my expensive addiction. She had just graduated from Hope College that summer and was settling in a routine of teaching ballet for first through fifth grade students at a local elementary school. Virtue had barely walked in the door that day before I nailed her with all of my complaints and accusations.â
âSuch as?â
âIt didnât matter, man. Anything I could think of, I was saying it. I complained of not being able to find clean underwear because she hadnât done the laundry. I accused her of seeing another man because sheâd gotten home an hour later than normal that day. I complained about being hungry because she hadnât cooked dinner.â
âDid you really think she was seeing another man?â
âI was intoxicated, Chris. Drunk people are some of the worldâs most stupid people. I was smashed and I was an idiot. It wasnât about dinner or the laundry, and it sure wasnât about another man. I knew Virtue better than that. If she really wanted to be with another man, she would have just