poacher, and the poacher shot him, and Wilfred saw it, and the poacher chased him and shot him to prevent him telling, thatâs how it looks to me.â
âWhat, a poacher in daylight?â
âNay, it might have been in tâdark. Or twilight falling dark.â
âThatâs so.â
When Wilfredâs lifeless corpse was carried across the threshold of his home, Emily gave a great cry and fell unconscious, clutching at her sonâs cold hands as she fell. She lay in bed for several days, hardly moving. Simon, seeing her so distraught, understood better the magnitude of her collapse after Harryâs demise. He gave her tender and unceasing care.
Meanwhile, the account of the course of events which Simon had devised to cover the two deaths was generally accepted, and the thought of an imaginary poacher filled menâs minds. An entirely innocent man who hadâit came out at the inquest and he admitted it franklyâbeen shooting that afternoon on the free, unleased portion of the moor, was suspected, questioned, arrested, brought before the Annotsfield magistrates, remanded in custody. When this suspicion was first voiced to Simon he was staggered. But he instantly commanded himself.
âI hope he gets off,â he thought, âbut I canât tell the truth, choose how. It would kill Emily. Nay, I know nowt of it,â he said aloud in a worried tone. âI just donât know. I heard shots on the moor that afternoon, thatâs true.â
By the time resumed hearing before the magistrates took place, Emily was well enough to attend, and insisted upon doing so.
Some Annotsfield men who did not know Simonâs reputation as an honest man and a good father had been giving him rather odd looks lately when he went to the town on errands, so as Simon set out for the magistratesâ court he felt quite uncertain as to whether he would return thence as an accused murderer or no. Accordingly he dressed himself very neatly, and shaved with special care. As he climbed the steps to the court, with Emily and Alice in deep mourning beside him, he felt himself the mark of every eye, and carried himself with stony dignity. In spite of his short stature and thinning hair, his appearance commanded respect; the lofty carriage of his large head showed him as a man not lightly to be distrusted. The innocent accused, pale and hangdog, looked far more guilty than he, reflected Simon with satisfaction.
This time, however, the accused man had secured from somewhere a sharp shrewd counsel, who produced and provedânot perhaps quite to the hilt but enough to convince any reasonable mindâan alibi for his client. The magistrates recalled Simon to the witness box.
âHold hard,â he urged himself as he calmly rose. âKeep the secret.â
He set his jaw, advanced with a firm regular tread and gave his replies in a quiet steady tone.
The magistrate took him again through his own meagre story of the day of the murder, and then, to his surprise, began to ask him questions about Wilfred.
âWas the boy quite normal?â
âHe was a little backward,â replied Simon.
âHow backward?â
âWellâhe couldnât read very well.â
âAt twelve years old?â
âHis mother was trying to teach him,â said Simon rather hastily, alive to a hint of censure.
âBackward, yes. But was he ever violent?â
âNever,â said Simon emphatically. âHe was a gentle, eager boy.â
âWas he fond of his uncle?â
âHis uncle?â repeated Simon, amazed.
âHis uncle, William Brearley. Had his uncle not scolded him at times?â
With a shock Simon perceived that they suspected Wilfred of having shot his uncle and then himself, and Simon of having come upon the body and to conceal his sonâs crime removed the gun and buried Wilfred. This might have been a convenient hypothesis but for its effect upon Emily,