window in his parentsâ house. On top of a low hill, the structure sat higher than theirs, and Jonah had often imagined how heâd grow up to raise a different sort of family there. A family that laughed together often. There would be pictures of grandparents â his wifeâs parents â on the mantel above the fireplace. Theyâd empty loose change from their pockets into a dish by the front door to spend on ice cream, instead of locked away in a metal box kept under the wood stove, with a mouse trap set on top. In the house on the hill, the pantry would always be lined with glass jars full of plums.
When Jonah and Hazel first arrived, Jonah stood on his porch and looked down their hill, wild with grasses, towards his parentsâ house that was surrounded by a yard of compact dirt and strewn with orderly accumulations of broken down machinery.
Jonahâs father looked over Hazel for the first time as she stood next to Jonah in their front door, twisting the thin gold ring on her finger. She was dressed in a pair of jeans and, because she hadnât been expecting company and it was a hot day in July, a blouse that was unbuttoned halfway from the bottom and tied into a knot. Her dark hair swung freely across her face.
âDoesnât seem to me sheâs likely to last long out here,â he said to Jonah. The same way he might have talked about a cow that wasnât fat enough to produce milk.
Jonahâs father had taken off his hat when he knocked on the coupleâs door, even though Jonah knew he had no mind to come inside. Now he hit the hat against his hand to indicate heâd said what he came to say, and a puff of dust was expelled into the air. He waved it away before he set the grubby old fedora back on his head. âJust see that she isnât a burden to me and your mother. Weâre too old to put up with trouble on account of someone who canât pull her own weight.â At barely fifty, Jonahâs father wasnât old enough to have been busy dying for so many years.
Hazel stood at the door for a moment longer before gently pushing it closed.
âWe should have gone over to see them as soon as we got here,â Hazel said when she turned around and faced her husband. She was anxiously unknotting her blouse and tucking it into her waistband. Jonah watched for a sign that she was hurt, or disgusted, by his fatherâs behaviour. That she was angry at Jonah for not telling her before what kind of a miserable old bugger the man was.
âFirst they couldnât make it out for our wedding and now this. Your parents must feel so left out. We should go over right away and apologize.â Hazel looked around her and picked up a basket of jams and crackers â a wedding gift from a favourite teacher â from the kitchen table and stepped towards the door.
âApologize?â Jonah said. âHe just insulted you. He should be the one to apologize.â
âYes. But he wonât, will he?â Hazel said, surprising Jonah.
âThereâs no point.â
âThere is. Even if not for them.â It didnât matter that Jonah didnât understand, because in that moment he believed her. He would have believed her if she said pigs laid eggs. And two years later, he still believed her when they had Katie. Even after his father bent over her crib and shook his head. Nobody had asked him, he said, whether he wanted to be a grandfather.
âHeâs sick in his heart. He canât help himself,â Hazel said after Jonahâs father had left.
âI suppose.â Jonah lifted Katie from Hazelâs arms and looked into her sleepy face. âIt doesnât matter, though.â
When Katie was old enough, Jonah taught her how to take fresh eggs from under their hens, the way his Aunt Ardelle had taught him. He knew, and it pleased him, that sometimes his father would be out in his own yard and see