just one kind of person. Ever since sheâd written in my autograph book, I was afraid that goodness was what she really wanted out of me.
âBe good, sweet child,â she had written, âand let who will be clever.â
Deep in my heart I knew that goodness didnât come natural to me. If I had to choose, I would rather be clever, but I didnât understand why anyone had to choose. I wasnât even sure that people could choose, although my mother was always saying that if they really tried, people could be whatever they wanted to be. But that was just more grown-up talk. As if wanting to be beautiful (like my mother) could make one bit of difference in my looks. As if trying to beat up Ian Forbes could do anything but land me in trouble. As for being good, I had to admit that I didnât always want to be.
Dear Grandma (I wrote in my next letter): I want to warn you so you wonât be disappointed. Iâm not always good. Sometimes I donât even try.
It was true. I knew I wasnât supposed to go to the Mud Flats alone, but twice I had managed to sneak off for a quick visit. The boat was gone, already at home on the river, I supposed, but my little friend was there. Each time he had run up to greet me and I had given him an orange. Each time he had called me âAmerican friendâ and had walked me back to the Bund.
Of course I knew I was wrong to disobey my mother but that hadnât stopped me. Still, I did feel guilty. If my name had been Marjorie, I thought, I would not have been the sort of person to feel guilty. And if it had not been the end of November, with Christmas already in the air, I might not have thought of the perfect way to solve my problem.
âI know what you can give me for Christmas,â I told my mother.
âIâve already bought your presents.â My mother was writing letters at her little black lacquer desk and she didnât look up.
âThis wouldnât cost a thing,â I explained. âIt would be easy.â
âWell?â She still didnât look up.
âYou could give me a new name. Thatâs what I really want.â
Now she did look up. She even put down her pen. âAnd what, may I ask, is the matter with the name you have?â
âI donât like it. Take it back.â I put my arm around her neck because I didnât want her to feel bad about the mistake sheâd made. âGive me the name Marjorie. Just write it on a gift card and put it in a box. You see how easy it would be.â
My mother shook her head as if she couldnât understand how Iâd got into the family. âI wouldnât name a cat Marjorie,â she said.
Well, of course not! âMarjorie is not a catâs name,â I yelled. And I stamped out of the room.
When I asked my father, he simply changed the subject. âI know one present you are getting for Christmas,â he said, âthat youâve never even thought of.â
He was a good subject-changer.
âAnimal, vegetable, or mineral?â I asked.
âVegetable.â
âHow heavy?â
âAs heavy as a pound of butter.â Heâd give me no more clues, but of course I did give it a lot of thought between then and Christmas.
But I hadnât forgotten about Marjorie. I was going to Andreaâs for the weekend and I would see what she thought.
I loved going to the Hullsâ. Not only did they have low ceilings and three children (Andrea, Edward, and David, the adopted one), but the Hull family was different from any I had ever known. They must have believed in goodness because, like us, they were a Y.M.C.A. family, but what they stressed was being free and natural. When the family was alone, for instance, they thought nothing of walking around upstairs without any clothes on. The way Andrea spoke, it was as if she hardly noticed if her parents were naked or not. Moreover, the Hulls seemed to talk together about