lit, andââ
âMusic editor?â repeated Ashley. âHow stupid. Thereâs nothing to do except get the captions right under the concert choir photographs.â
âThatâs exactly what I said, but the editor told me to come up with something innovative and unique.â
âIâve been doing things that are innovative and unique for years now,â said Ashley, âand none of them would fit into a yearbook.â
My mother definitely did not want to hear about any innovative and unique activities Ashley might have gotten into. âWhat a nice color sweater you have on, dear,â she said. âI love it on you.â
I almost gave her as disgusted a look as Ashley did. âItâs the only thing the Salvation Army had,â said my sister.
âOh, honey, why didnât you call us?â cried my mother. âI would have sent you money! I would have sent you clothing.â
âI didnât want to hear your voice.â
Another chilling remark. Delivered simply, as one stating an obvious factâsay, that the Atlantic Ocean separates us from Europe. I didnât want to hear your voice.
Mom began serving pot roast. Her hands were shaking. My father was not looking at Ashley, but at Mom, and rather sadly. Suddenly I knew that my mother was desperateâfranticâfor proof that she was not a failed mother. That daughter number one really was a neat little suburbanite underneath it all. But Dad knew better. And his grief was for his wife, not for Ashley.
I stared at them all, and I did not know where my grief lay.
But I understood something I had never thought about, or known existed. Our house was run gently and smoothly because my mother was fragileânot Ashley. Ashley, thin and tired and defeated as she might be, had the strength of ten. My mother did not.
âWhere have you been, Ash?â I said, unable to resist the topic. âDetroit? Dallas?â
âEvery city in America has a roach-ridden, urine-stinking motel where I have slept,â she said. âI have peddled my act in every corner of this worthless nation.â
I could see my father getting ready to defend America against the charge of worthlessness. We had enough troubles without bringing America into it. âYouâre in luck,â I said lightly. âWe feature hot showers and roach-free accommodations.â
Ashley gave me a long assessing look. I did not know if I got a passing grade or not. But at least I was getting a chance, which was more than Mom and Dad got. She poked at her food. âI guess thatâs as good a reason as any,â she said finally.
My heart ached.
Whenever my mother is upset, she eats. The more she heard Ashleyâs flat dead voice, the more she ate. She piled the mashed potatoes onto her plate and added enough gravy to float them out to sea.
âYou got fat,â Ashley accused her. âFat people have no discipline. Theyâre slovenly.â
My mother sat very still.
My father sucked in a deep furious breath.
âItâs only five or ten pounds, Ash,â I said instantly. âI donât call that fat. I call it minor padding.â I smiled at my sister, willing her not to make things worse.
âOh, Christ,â said my sister wearily. âYouâre one of these sugar-and-cream types, arenât you? Always finding the silver lining. Do me a favor, Susan?â
âSure.â
âShut up.â
There was a long, long pause. Nobody ate. Four forks played games on four plates. I had rather hastily jumped to the conclusion that I, Susan Anne, would be the savior in a difficult situation. Ashley had rather hastily pointed out to me that no, I wouldnât.
My father said, âWeâre glad youâre home, Ashley. Weâre glad you knew you could come home. But I am going to have to require you to be courteous to your mother and your sister if youâre going to live