Theodora. âI shall leave you together. You know him, donât you? If anyone can help us it is he!â
She left them in a dramatic and purposeful way, shutting the door firmly behind her.
Molly Caplan smiled.
âYouâre not fooled, are you?â she said. âTheodoraâs terribly upset, really. You mustnât think because she behaves like Ophelia that sheâs not suffering. I know she is.â
âIâm sure she must be. Yet I canât help feeling that in some way she enjoys that suffering.â
âCould be,â said Molly Caplan sharply. âWhat do you want to know from me?â
âTo be frank, I canât really say. Anything you like to tell me, I suppose.â
âDo I think heâs left her, for example. No, I donât. It was a strange relationship, but they were fond of each other. He was a bore with all his health and fitness and she as you know is a tragedy queen, but somehow it worked. He would have said he made allowances for her, but really she did for him. A man in his sixties who did physical jerks before a window every morning and threatened to take up yoga canât have been easy to live with. Iâve been in the house five years and Iâd describe them, without hesitation, as a happily married couple.â
âYou think he confided in her?â
âThere was nothing much to confide. He never talked about his business, if thatâs what you mean.â
âNever? Did
you
know for instance that Thripp wanted to sell their practice and Duncan Humby wouldnât hear of it?â
âAs a matter of fact I did. Lionel Thripp is an old friend of mine. It was through him I came to look after Theodora and Duncan. But I think itâs perfectly possible that Theodora didnât know that. Duncan made a point of not talking shop.â
âSo she would not have any idea where he was going that day?â
âNone, I should say. Not an inkling.â
âHad you?â
âWhat?â
âAn inkling?â
For the first time Molly Caplan looked a little uncomfortable.
âI donât see why you should ask. How can it possibly help your enquiries?â
âIt may not. But someone must have known, apart from Thripp.â
âYes. I knew. But not from Duncan Humby. I think we wonât go into that any farther.â
âAll right. Just tell me how long you had known?â
âWell, since the previous evening. Now â¦â
âWhatâs your theory, Mrs. Caplan?â
âDonât have one. But it looks pretty ugly to me. Duncanâs an obstinate man. Someone might have to kill him before heâd give in.â
âUnless he could be fooled or persuaded into something incautious,â
âMost unlikely,â
âYou have a car, Mrs. Caplan?â
She stared at him.
âWhat on
earth â¦â
âNothing, really,â said Carolus, smiling. âItâs a question I may have to ask several people in Newminster. Call it a formality.â
âI have a car, yes,â said Molly Caplan sulkily.
âDid you use it that Monday?â
âThis is absurd, you know. Mondays are my days off. Naturally I used my car.â
âBut you donât feel like telling me where you went?â
âI certainly donât. I find your questions impertinent and foolish.â
âThey must seem so. Iâm sorry. Will you at least tell me at what time you took your car out?â
âImmediately after lunch, of course.â
âAnd you returned?â
âBefore midnight. Now thatâs enough.â
âYour car is a â¦â
âFord Consul. Blue,â snapped Molly Caplan and stood up as though to dismiss him.
Carolus left the house after going back to say goodbye to Theodora. He had a pretty shrewd idea of the two women, if nothing else.
He decided to go over to Hallows End next day, and was irritated to find thick fog. Last